Howdy, stranger! Ready to join the community? [log in]

Gaming Keyboard Roundup: Logitech, OCZ, and Razer

With OCZ’s new line of gaming hardware coming to fruition, the Alchemy Elixir keyboard has reached the market. Featuring low-profile keys, ten dedicated macro keys, and rubberized texture, we’re pitting it against two of today’s reigning gaming keyboards to see how they match up.

First off, I’ll elaborate a bit on the Razer Lycosa, one of the high-profile gaming boards available today. Razer is certainly a company known around the gaming community, creating everything ranging from ridiculously-sensitive mice to gaming headsets. While I’m not one to be impressed by packaging, Razer’s Lycosa boxing is astounding. More often than not, I get furious with packaging for uselessly getting in my way and keeping me away from my goodies. Everything about the Lycosa, however, says that this product was designed for gamers. Even if it comes off as a bit over the top, its mission accomplished. You know they’re not messing around.

The well-organized keys are slick and shiny with a rubbery tactility that feels solid to the touch. In an unusual move, the wrist rest doesn’t just snap onto the board; it actually screws into the bottom of the Lycosa. It is clear Razer puts great thought into their products by eliminating any chance that the wrist rest could fall off at an inopportune time. The mounted wrist rest also grants the keyboard a little extra stability. Razer’s dedication to gamers also shines through in the lighting options for the Lycosa. In addition to no and full backlighting, the user can also enable backlighting for the WASD cluster alone.

Both the full and WASD-only backlighting options are in a pleasant shade of blue. The various lighting profiles can be changed on the fly with a button in the multimedia control key cluster. This cluster contains global hotkeys for play/pause, stop, forward, back, and volume up/down, though a mute button is curiously absent. Amongst the multimedia keys is the Razer logo key which allows a user to change profiles when combined with a function key, or enter “game mode” if combined with the Windows key. Game mode will disable the Windows keys so you can’t be kicked out of your frag-fest by accidentally hitting one.

The keyboard connects with two USB plugs and a standard pair of headphone/microphone 1/8″ mini-jacks. The second USB cable activates a USB 2.0 port on the rear of the keyboard, while the 1/8″ jacks activate headphone and microphone outlets next door. This will allow you to plug your mouse and headset directly into the keyboard, reducing wire clutter at the back of your case.

The robust Lycosa software allows you to remap absolutely any non-multimedia key to a 16-keystroke macro, a specific Windows command (cut, copy, close window, lock PC, show desktop), a program, or one of up to ten profiles at a time. The software also records mouse clicks, permits the insertion of delays in 50ms intervals up to 200ms, or will repeat your actions verbatim. You can tell the Lycosa to only run the macro once, repeat it while it’s held down, or repeat it until you touch the next key. You can even entirely disable the key. As mentioned, key profiles are enabled with the Razor+Function Key stroke, or can be configured to load when a certain executable launches. Lastly, the software allows you to back up key sets and profiles for portability and crash-protection.

Not all is well, though, as there were four quirks that were disappointing for me. While every key that is not mapped can be a potential macro key, the lack of dedicated macro buttons irked me. Secondly, the touch panel that contains the multimedia cluster and the Razer key was often unresponsive. Thirdly, the lack of tactile response for the media cluster also makes it difficult to know if the key of choice was properly activated. Lastly, removal of the wrist rest left a peculiar notch cut in the front edge of the keyboard.

If you’re a user of Windows Media Player, you’ll be disappointed to learn that the play/pause button forces Windows to focus the Windows Media Player Client. Tapping the play/pause button forces Windows Media Player to blink on the task bar, open from a minimized state, or become the active window. This behavior is baffling given that keyboards like the Logitech G15 can manipulate media playback without ever shifting focus from the current active window. This behavior was replicated on both Windows XP and Windows Vista.

Next page »

Related:

View or reply via discussion forum.

22 Replies:

  1. Winfrey
    Tits Maggee!

    Shiny keyboards!

  2. rolleggroll
    Love by the TSA

    Snarky your write-up has gotten me all hyped up to buy an Alchemy Elixir. If this thing sucks after I buy it...its on your head.

  3. PurplezArctic
    Crashing out at supermarts.

    Hmm.. got me thinking about getting a new board.

    I like the OCZ macro buttons are arranged vertically as to cut the length down.

  4. Matt Jancaitis
    Master Icrontian

    (So are the G15's)

  5. PurplezArctic
    Crashing out at supermarts.

    Hmm. Why didn't I remember that ...

    How about,

    I like the OCZ macro buttons are arranged in such a way to cut down length. As in one column on each end of the board.

  6. Matt Jancaitis
    Master Icrontian

    (The G15 only has one column of keys)

    Perhaps this is where I mention that the G15 is smaller in width than the Alchemy Elixir. It IS, however, taller, thanks to the GamePanel.

  7. PurplezArctic
    Crashing out at supermarts.

    Ah, I still have the image of the earlier generation G15 in my head, where it has the 3 clusters of 6 buttons (right?) on one side.

    I suppose it's quite obvious I didn't read the reviews thoroughly.

  8. Matt Jancaitis
    Master Icrontian

    Yes indeed, the former iteration had quite the load of keys. There are pictures of the board in the review and here.

  9. TurboPenguin
    LAN Addict

    I'm surprised that Saitek's Cyborg Keyboard wasn't included in this...

  10. Thrax
    The Lulzbringer

    Saitek didn't send us a review sample.

  11. Winfrey
    Tits Maggee!

    Their loss imho.

  12. Matt Jancaitis
    Master Icrontian

    I would be glad to write something up if they'd send one, though!

  13. troll
    Folding Troll

    I have one of the 1st gen G15's with the 18 macro keys...
    The LCD is excellent, many games will load custom stuff on the panel, also nice to have FRAPS running on the LCD instead of flickering on the monitor.
    You really get used to the backlit keys, I'll always have a keyboard with it.
    Good review, I like the look of the 2nd gen G15.

  14. primesuspect
    The Icrontic Guy

    I too have the 1st-gen G15, and I love it. best keyboard I ever owned.

  15. Thrax
    The Lulzbringer
    I too have the 1st-gen G15, and I love it. best keyboard I ever owned.
  16. GnomeWizardd
    I Bleed TF2

    maybe should throw in the G11 since it is only 50 bucks now nad still one of the best in my opinion

  17. UPSWeezer
    Ninja Warrior

    Are the keys on the OCZ Elixer quiet?

    I might get one.

  18. Matt Jancaitis
    Master Icrontian

    Not terribly quiet, no.

  19. UPSWeezer
    Ninja Warrior

    I'm liking this one as well.

    Spectre Gamer Keyboard KUT2

  20. Matt Jancaitis
    Master Icrontian

    Just a heads up: you can get the G15, whose recommendation I stand by, for $62 today. Just a small premium over your current choice for a lot of added value.

    Note: I missed that that was a refurb, but there are similar deals for new ones here and here.

  21. UPSWeezer
    Ninja Warrior
    Just a heads up: you can get the G15, whose recommendation I stand by, for $62 today. Just a small premium over your current choice for a lot of added value.

    Note: I missed that that was a refurb, but there are similar deals for new ones here and here.

    Oh thanks. Very nice.

  22. paul
    Guest

    I like the sound of this, the Alchemy Elixir keyboard could be exactly what I have been looking for.

Hey, be nice. Icrontic is full of good people, we promise.