Recommendations Please for Two PC Rebuilds

To talk on Icrontic, just register!

It only takes 30 seconds.

Have an account? Sign in:

Reply to Discussion

Options

Leonardo

Buzzwinkle the Moose FTW

14,843 Posts

4 Jun 2003, 12:09pm

Recommendations Please for Two PC Rebuilds

Need your comments, advice, and recommendations please for major upgrades I'll be performing to my two home computers when I return from the Middle East.

Here's what I've got:

System 1: Abit KX7333-R, Athlon XP2100, 512MB Samsung 2700, 2XWD800BB in RAID 0 config; Radeon 8500 LE 64MB, Alpha 8045 cooler, all in Global Win spacious aluminum case;

System 2: Abit KR7A-R, Athlon XP1900, 512MB Twinmoss 2700, 2XWD600BB in RAID 0 config, Radeon 8500 LE 128 MB; Alpha 8045 cooler, all in Antec (SOHO - forgot number) case;

Both systems have excellent, spacious cases, with good quality PSUs. Intent for new systems is only moderate (if any) overclocking. I want high performance, but instead of RAID and overclocking, my pursuit will be quiet operation, matched with first class speed. I will not be on benchmark quests but want snappy machines.

I am dead set on building an Intel machine. I've already built severeal Athlon machines and really want to add Intel to my repertoir.

Both machines will each have two hard drives - the second drive serving as an image drive. I'm religious about Ghosting my systems for backups. I do not intend to run RAID. Been doing that for two years now, and am tired of all the extra cables and extra variables when dealing with Windows installation. I do though, want RAID motherboards for the flexibility the extra HDD ports offer. I will tweak both machines as far as I can without raising temperatures and without compromising stability. I want minimum fans in both towers.

OK, here are my proposals. Please heap your comments, criticism and whatnot on me:

System 1 (Intel):
-- Mobo: MSI NEO FIS2R --EDIT - change to Abit IC7-- (Intel Canterwood, hyperthreading (800MHz FSB-4X200, 400MHz Memory)
-- CPU: Intel P4, 2800MHz, 800 FSB, Hyperthreading) (3.0+ GHz if prices fall soon)
-- Memory, PC3200, 2X512 Geil "Value Ultra" CAS 2.5/6-3-3 -2T (1024 MB of DDR at 2.5 CAS is more important to me than 512MB or high performance CAS 2; these 512 sticks at Newegg for $69).
-- HDD: WD800JB, 8MB cache
-- Video Card: use existing Radeon 8500LE 128MB -
-- This machine is for general purpose, consisting of heavy office applications, Folding, and some gaming.

System 2 (AMD):
-- Mobo: Abit NF7-S v2.0, (nForce 2-SPP Chipset, SATA RAID, Serillel adaptor)
-- CPU: AMD XP 2800 Barton, 400MHz FSB (XP 3000 Barton if prices fall soon)
-- Memory, PC3200, 2X512 Geil "Value Ultra" CAS 2.5/6-3-3 -2T (1024 MB of DDR at 2.5 CAS is more important to me than 512MB or high performance CAS 2; these 512 sticks at Newegg for $69).
-- HDD: WD800JB, 8MB cache
-- Video Card - ATI 9500 PRO if still available when I purchase parts
-- This machine is for general purpose, with emphasis on gaming and folding. Office applications of type also.

Leo

__________________ HEATWARE 208/0/0

1. Gigabyte GA-P35-DS4, Q6600/G0 3.2GHz, Seasonic M12D 850 PSU, 4GB OCZ DDR2 800, 2 X EVGA 9800GX2, TR Ultra120E; 2. Gigabyte EP45-UPD3, Q6600/G0 3.2GHz, BFG EX 1000 PSU, 4GB G.Skill DDR2 800, ECS 9800GX2, EVGA 9800GX2, Prolimatech Megahalems; 3. Gigabyte GA-X38-DS4, Q6600/G0 3.2GHz, Cooler Master RS-850-EMBA PSU, 4GB G.Skill DDR2 800, 2 X EVGA 9800GX2, Prolimatech Megahalems; 4. Gigabyte GA-P35-DS4, Q6600/G0 3.2GHz, Cooler Master RS-850-EMBA PSU, 4GB Patriot DDR2 800, PNY 9800GX2, EVGA 9800GX2, Prolimatech Megahalems

Reply with Quote

Thrax

Cad

24,029 Posts

4 Jun 2003, 12:47pm

Why ask?

The only thing I'd change is the Barton 2800+ to a 3200+.

__________________ Robert Hallock
Technical Analyst
Twitter | LinkedIn

CPU: Core 2 Duo E6420 @ 3.5GHz (500*7)
MoBo: DFI LanParty DK P35-T2R/S
RAM: 4GB G.SKILL PC8500
VID: NVIDIA GeForce GTX 275
HSF: Thermalright Ultra-120

Reply with Quote

Omega65

EPoX Evangelist!

2,891 Posts

4 Jun 2003, 1:00pm

Nix the MSI and go for one of the Abit IC7 series (either IC7-S or IC7-G) (can't recommend an EPOX as they aren't available

)

Hardocp: IC7-G Review

And even though I'm a staunch AMD supporter, I think a i875 Mobo and a P4 2.4C or 2.6C is a compelling value. If I were building another single CPU system this year this is what I would buy.

A 3.2-3.6ghz OC is a fast system no matter what app you run on it....

As for the Athlon system the Barton 2800+ (2.083ghz)or 3000+ (2.167ghz) are good choices (Nix the 3200+ its only 2.20ghz @ FSB400 and the 3000+ can be set to that level at stock voltage - save the cash)

The Abit NF7-S v2.0 is currently the best Athlon motherboard available - Good choice.

__________________ Moderator: System Core Forum - Got a question??...shoot me a PM

Dell E1705 Core Duo 1.66ghz 1GB X1400 100GB
DFI NF4 SLI-DR - Opty 170 @ 2.5ghz - 7900GT - 2GB Corsair PC4400 Pro - Raptor 74GB
Abit AV8 - X2 4400+ @ 2.5ghz - 2GB G.Skill PC4000 - Raptor 74GB

Heatware: Omega65 150-0-0
Ebay Feedback Omega365 62-0-0

Athlon 64 Comparison: 12 CPUs - Single vs Dual Channel - 512K vs 1MB Cache

Reply with Quote

Omega65 edited : 4 Jun 2003 at 1:08pm .

TheLostSwede

Where's the ****ing beers?

3,220 Posts

4 Jun 2003, 1:08pm

Leo,

You are right about the memory on the Canterwood. Canterwood LOVES fsb and low timings, Amd rigs the opposite.

I would suggest that you get 2 X Twinmos sticks, no, Twinmos for both systems actually. Twinmos can be hard to get in the states, but i found a guy with a thread at amdmb in their Deal and Depot that sells them or make sure to get those.

http://www.amdforums.com/showthread....hreadid=206235

As for the harddrives, why not go for 2 Western Digital Raptors (36 gb each) and a 80 gb WD se for backup? SATA is on that MSI board, im sure. Im using the SATA adaptors now and the cable mess are unbelievable.

Is watercooling out of the question?
Nothing is more quiet than that.

I want a Canterwood as well.

__________________ ...

Reply with Quote

mmonnin

Veteran Icrontian

10,545 Posts

4 Jun 2003, 2:00pm

I must is the 875P chipset from Inte and 2 sticks of PC3200. 6.4gbs worth of bandwidth then and thats how much the P4 needs. The P4 NEEDS Dual Channel. There is finally a technology that can handle the bandwidth of a P4. Thats why it was always better to run P4s async.

The Abit board looks good. If you get the Abit make sure its the G version. This will cost you well over $200, so be aware.

__________________ Stanford Team Stats_____________Team Short-Media
Statsman Team Stats______________EOC Team Stats

Reply with Quote

edcentric

Must keep folding

2,481 Posts

4 Jun 2003, 3:22pm

You need to check some recent memory reviews. There is a real gain in performance going to cas2.
If you want to keep them quiet then move to coolers that use 90mm fans. I like the Thermalright but there are others also.

__________________ A couple of folding boxes;

DFI LP Nf4 U-D, A64X2, 2GB ram, is folding again
MSI P965 Pt, C2D E6300, 2GB ram, old reliable

2.5 million points and counting

Reply with Quote

Leonardo

Buzzwinkle the Moose FTW

14,843 Posts

4 Jun 2003, 4:02pm

Oh, good feedback guys, keep it coming, please.

The only thing I'd change is the Barton 2800+ to a 3200+.

Uh, price! Besides, from what I've been able to gather so far, there isn't much of a real-world performance difference between the 2.8 and 3.2 - huge price stepping though. I just thought that the 2.8 seemed to have the best performance for the price. Maybe I'm wrong.

"...and 2 sticks of RAM.."

Absolutely! Dual channel. That's why I selected the Geil CAS 2.5 - 512MB sticks at Newegg for $69 each. I don't think I could afford quality CAS2 RAM, not for 2X512 for two computers. I'm thinking quantity over quality this time. We're talking $138 shipped for 1024 MB PC3200. Are you thinking I'd have better performance with only 512 (2X256) at CAS 2? Up to this point, I've always run at CAS 2.

Omega65 - I'll check out that Abit IG7 review. I've had four Abit boards, and enjoyed all of them. They MSI intrigued me - Anandtech called it their best Canterwood board so far.

Mack - I've got Twinmoss in my second system at home (PC2700). Again, I'm looking at a a Gig of DDR for each machine. Also, I probably won't be overclocking much.

The fan comment. Yeah I hear you. My goal is to run the system with nothing louder than Panaflo L series - that's why I probably won't be overclocking!

Thanks guys. It'll probably be about three weeks or more before I get around to upgrading, so keep the comments coming!

Leo

Reply with Quote

edcentric

Must keep folding

2,481 Posts

4 Jun 2003, 4:32pm

Leo,
Why not split the diff and buy one cas2 pair and one slower. Then you could see which mobo it made the most difference on. You will have a uniqe opportunity to swap memory between the two. You find that in one it doesn't matter.

Good luck getting a flight out.

Reply with Quote

Leonardo

Buzzwinkle the Moose FTW

14,843 Posts

4 Jun 2003, 4:52pm

Omega, I did check out the IC7-G review at HardOCP - very well-written review by the way.

Very impressive performance, stability, and flexibility with that board. Definitely close to a masterpiece, if there is such a thing in the mobo world. But dang, that board costs $220! A bit too rich for me. I checked out the IC7 (no "G"). It has the features and performance I want, but does not yet accept 400MHz DDR. Maybe by the time a purchase, Abit will have the next revision IC7 out.

Reply with Quote

TheLostSwede

Where's the ****ing beers?

3,220 Posts

4 Jun 2003, 5:29pm

I have Twinmos in both 3200 and 3700 versions. On my board, they perform almost the same. 215 FSB cas 2 with no mods at all on the board isnt that bad.

That gives about 3200/32XX in sandra benches. On a Canterwood, the same sticks would do around 4500/4500 i think.

Theres no use at all for the dual memory thing on Nforce 2 unfortunatly, you can hardly notice any difference at all.

Reply with Quote

Omega65

EPoX Evangelist!

2,891 Posts

4 Jun 2003, 8:54pm

Leonardo said
Omega, I did check out the IC7-G review at HardOCP - very well-written review by the way.

Very impressive performance, stability, and flexibility with that board. Definitely close to a masterpiece, if there is such a thing in the mobo world. But dang, that board costs $220! A bit too rich for me. I checked out the IC7 (no "G"). It has the features and performance I want, but does not yet accept 400MHz DDR. Maybe by the time a purchase, Abit will have the next revision IC7 out.

Leo: Welcome to the highpriced world of Intel

A good i875P mobo can cost more than a Dual Athlon mobo (which will be faster & more responsive in General use, but not in games)

Mac is right - P4s need Bandwidth (Cas2 or Cas3 - sunc/async - it doesn't matter) while with Athlons Cas2 > Cas2.5 > Cas3 (sucks) And ONLY run Synchronous (FSB/Memory) Async ALWAYS performs worse than Sync for any chosen FSB

Reply with Quote

TekGamer

I used to be an xXUSERXx

102 Posts

4 Jun 2003, 9:35pm

I have agree with Omega on the intel system.. ditch the MSI and go with the abit board. (ic7 or ic7g

tek

__________________ Torn between the light and the dark side of the force....

Reply with Quote

mmonnin

Veteran Icrontian

10,545 Posts

4 Jun 2003, 10:04pm

Kingston HyperX 2*256 PC3200 Case 2. 512mb is enough I think.

http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProduc...roperty&DEPA=1

Reply with Quote

danball1976

Veteran Icrontian

2,633 Posts

4 Jun 2003, 10:59pm

Leonardo said
OK, here are my proposals. Please heap your comments, criticism and whatnot on me:

System 1 (Intel):
-- Mobo: MSI NEO FIS2R (Intel Canterwood, hyperthreading (800MHz FSB-4X200, 400MHz Memory)
-- CPU: Intel P4, 2800MHz, 800 FSB, Hyperthreading) (3.0+ GHz if prices fall soon)
-- Memory, PC3200, 2X512 Geil "Value Ultra" CAS 2.5/6-3-3 -2T (1024 MB of DDR at 2.5 CAS is more important to me than 512MB or high performance CAS 2; these 512 sticks at Newegg for $69).
-- HDD: WD800JB, 8MB cache
-- Video Card: use existing Radeon 8500LE 64MB
-- This machine is for general purpose, consisting of heavy office applications, Folding, and some gaming.

System 2 (AMD):
-- Mobo: Abit NF7-S v2.0, (nForce 2-SPP Chipset, SATA RAID, Serillel adaptor)
-- CPU: AMD XP 2800 Barton, 400MHz FSB (XP 3000 Barton if prices fall soon)
-- Memory, PC3200, 2X512 Geil "Value Ultra" CAS 2.5/6-3-3 -2T (1024 MB of DDR at 2.5 CAS is more important to me than 512MB or high performance CAS 2; these 512 sticks at Newegg for $69).
-- HDD: WD800JB, 8MB cache
-- Video Card - to be determined
-- This machine is for general purpose, with emphasis on gaming and folding. Office applications of type also.

Video card for System 2. I don't want to shell out the money for top of the line, but I'd like something superior to the Radeon 8500LE - but it would have to by a high enough performance increase to justify its cost.

PLEASE MAKE VID CARD COMMENTS IN THE GRAPHICS AND SOUND SUB-FORUM -- http://short-media.com/forum/showthr...s=&threadid=63 .

Thanks in advance for your advice!

Leo

Go with system 2 - AMD all the way

__________________

Visit my Deviant Art profile - Visit my Fur Affinity profile

Reply with Quote

mmonnin

Veteran Icrontian

10,545 Posts

4 Jun 2003, 11:03pm

Look in his sig:

1. Intel 875P Canterwood - P4 being drawn up.
2. nForce2 SPP - AMD Barton being drawn up.
Both machines to be built when I return from the desert!

He is building both.

Reply with Quote

danball1976

Veteran Icrontian

2,633 Posts

4 Jun 2003, 11:11pm

mmonnin said
Look in his sig:

1. Intel 875P Canterwood - P4 being drawn up.
2. nForce2 SPP - AMD Barton being drawn up.
Both machines to be built when I return from the desert!

He is building both.

Oh, ok.

I don't usually pay attention to small sigs like that. All that money he got from being where he is currently is going towards the computers.

Reply with Quote

muddocktor

Wandering about

6,250 Posts

7 Jun 2003, 11:36pm

Leo, Hardocp had some real issues with that MSI board and overclocking in this article right here , but since you don't plan to overclock much, this might not be an issue. Here is an excerpt from their conclusions:

Other than the overclocking issues, I was impressed with the board. The board had a very nice overall layout, with the exception of the upper row of capacitors along the CPU mounting cage and the CMOS reset jumper issue. The BIOS overclocking options were superb, giving great latitude in both voltage and FSB settings. That�s the strange thing with the overclocking problem � the board should have easily hit a 1 GHz CPU FSB, especially in light of the extreme voltage settings possible with the BIOS. There�s definitely something not quite right there.

Also, from what I've read at Overclockers.com in this article , it isn't necessary to run a sych fsb/mem speed so you could still have great performance running at a 5:4 or even a 3:2 ratio and still push that proc higher than stock speeds without worrying about your memory crapping out.

The WD hard drives for both systems are also a good choice, IMO. The price/performance ratio is simply totally against SATA drives for right now and the WD 800JB I have has performed well so far.

As far as the AMD system goes, I would buy a Barton XP2500 instead of the 2800 and just overclock it to 2800 or 3000 speeds because the 2500's are down to just $93 at Newegg nowdays. I agree with the Abit mobo as your choice as it seems to be the best nforce2 board out right now.

As for quiet cooling, I would stay with the stock Intel cooler if you don't plan to overclock it much and for the AMD system I would go with an SLK800 with a Delta FFB0812HHE fan, which is the quietest of the focused flow fans from Delta. I have 3 of them and they are pretty quiet. Use Panaflo L1A fans for your case fans and you should have 2 quiet running rigs.

Reply with Quote

Leonardo

Buzzwinkle the Moose FTW

14,843 Posts

9 Jun 2003, 5:54pm

I posted nearly the same thing in another thread, but it warrants being put here as well: This site is already developing into what was intended for it. It is becoming a computer tech-centric gathering place. Excellent advice and comments guys.

Now, concerning the Canterwood 875 chipset motherboard. The Abit IC7 is looking more attractive. Here's a summary of the board and its features:

(Copied from Newegg's Intel-Abit page)
ABIT IC7, Intel 875P chipset for Socket 478 P4 Canterwood ATX motherboard RETAIL
Specifications:
Supported CPU:Intel� Pentium� 4 Socket 478 processors
Chipset:Intel� 875P / ICH5 RAID
FSB:800/533MHz 400FSB not Supported
RAM:4x 184pin Dual Channel DDR 400 Max 4GB ECC Support
IDE:2 x Ultra DMA 33/66/100 Connectors up to 4 Devices
SATA: 2x SATA For RAID 0
Slots:1 x AGP PRO, 5 x PCI slots
Ports:2xPS2,1xLPT,1xCOM,2xUSB2.0,1x1394 and Audio
Onboard Audio: 6-Channel AC 97 CODEC on
Onboard IEEE 1394: IEEE 1394a at 100/200/400 Mb/s transfer rate Model#: IC7

-- "400FSB not Supported". That is my only reservation with this board at this time. Whatever the P4 processor that goes in this machine, it WILL be a 400MHz part.

Reply with Quote

mmonnin

Veteran Icrontian

10,545 Posts

9 Jun 2003, 6:25pm

400 means 100FSB*4. 100*4 compared to the 200*4 CPU that you want.

It will do what you want Leo.

Reply with Quote

muddocktor

Wandering about

6,250 Posts

9 Jun 2003, 6:39pm

Leo, I would suggest that you go with the 800 fsb P4 instead of a 533 or 400 fsb P4 as even the 2.4/800 has hyperthreading enabled and the lower fsb speed procs don't have HT any lower than 3.0. You're only paying $16.99 more for the 800/2.4 over the 400/2.4 for the oem proc and $22 more for the retail versions at Newegg. That's a good tradeoff to get hyperthreading, IMO.

The IC7 board looks like a nice board to use, you just have to put your own nic in it. I've heard that it overclocks real well too.

__________________ I have some computers running Seti@Home.

Reply with Quote

Leonardo

Buzzwinkle the Moose FTW

14,843 Posts

9 Jun 2003, 7:04pm

Mud, Mmonnin,

You guys are both correct. I've been winging through all this so fast that I've skimmed over some of the details too fast. Absolutely, the 800MHz "quad-pumped" (4X200) is exactly what I wanted, that's why I had only considered the 865 or 875 Intel chipsets in the first place. And yes, I had the 800MHz and 400MHz confused on this. If it weren't for the 875 or 865, I wouldn't have considered Intel this time around.

Thanks guys. It now looks like I'll be going with the Abit IC7. Abit family with and Intel and AMD children.

Reply with Quote

mmonnin

Veteran Icrontian

10,545 Posts

9 Jun 2003, 7:21pm

The dual channel finally makes Intel worth while I think. Still AMD fan here but you can finally run RAM and FSB sync and be able to have the same bandwidth. No more bottlenecks on the RAM side.

Reply with Quote

muddocktor

Wandering about

6,250 Posts

9 Jun 2003, 7:23pm

Sounds great, Leo. Ed over at overclockers.com has been liking his IC7 and has been getting some great overclocking results out of it too according to that article. I wouldn't mind building a P4 system with Springdale or Canterwood myself, if I had some extra money.

Reply with Quote

mmonnin

Veteran Icrontian

10,545 Posts

9 Jun 2003, 8:30pm

muddocktor said
..., if I had some extra money.

???

Reply with Quote

mmonnin

Veteran Icrontian

10,545 Posts

10 Jun 2003, 3:45pm

Leo: You might want to check this out at Anandtech.

865PE & 875P Memory Guide

Reply with Quote

Leonardo

Buzzwinkle the Moose FTW

14,843 Posts

10 Jun 2003, 4:03pm

Thanks. Interesting.

Reply with Quote

Leonardo

Buzzwinkle the Moose FTW

14,843 Posts

8 Jul 2003, 4:34am

Update

Well, all the parts are either ordered, procured, bargained for through private trades, or are in my present systems.

Here's how it stacks up (very close to what I had originally planned):

SYSTEM 1 (INTEL)
Mobo: Abit IC7 - Intel "Canterwood" 875 chipset, hyperthreading, 800MHz FSB-4X200, 400MHz Memory (Monarchcomputer.com)
-- CPU: Intel P4, 2800MHz, 800 FSB, Hyperthreading (private trade)
-- Memory, PC3200, 2X512 Geil "Value Ultra" CAS 2.5/6-3-3 -2T (1024 MB of DDR at 2.5 CAS is more important to me than 512MB of high performance CAS 2) (Newegg @$73/512MB module)
-- HDD: 2 X 80GB Maxtor Ultra, 8MB cache, RAID 0 config (Staples)
-- HDD: (Ghost - backup), Western Digital, WD800JB, 8MB cache (private trade)
-- Video Card: Radeon 9500 Pro (private trade)
-- rounded cables throughout (SVCompucycle - .99 to $2.49 each! sale is still on as of today! already installed in my current systems - work perfectly. Airflow IS better.)
-- PSU: Robontron 600W, absolutely super power supply, rock solid voltage lines at overclock (existing system - former private trade with Tex!)
-- HSF - stock Intel unit that will arrive with my P4 2.8. I'll hone the base and install one of my Mechatronics 80mm jobbers.
-- GlobalWin YCC 61F1 aluminum, homely, but oh-so-well engineered and spacious (present system)

SYSTEM 2 (AMD):
-- Mobo: Abit NF7-S v2.0, (nForce 2-SPP Chipset, SATA RAID (Monarch - guaranteed rev. 2.0)
-- CPU: AMD XP 2800 Barton (Newegg)
-- Memory, PC3200, 2X512 Geil "Value Ultra" CAS 2.5/6-3-3 -2T (Newegg)
-- HDD: WD800JB, 8MB cache (private trade)
-- HDD: (backup-Ghost) IBM GXP 60GB (from present system - hey, it's been perfectly reliable so far, and quite fast and quiet running)
-- Video Card - Radeon 8500LE 128MB OEM (from present system; may upgrade later to 9500 Pro)
-- PSU: Robontron 600W, absolutely super power supply, rock solid voltage lines at overclock (existing system - former private trade Tex!)
-- HSF: Alpha 8045/Mechatronics fan (present system)
-- Case: Chieftec (Antec 1030B) (present system)

I thought long and hard about my choice of the CAS 2.5 Geil RAM - not exactly head-spinning performance. I went through all the pros and cons of high-speed versus sheer volume. I opted for volume. Hey, what can I say - 2GB PC3200 CAS 2.5 for $292. Supposedly the RAM runs well in dual channel, NF2, and Intel 875 systems. We'll see.

Stock HSF unit for Intel box - I'll lap it well, slap on a Mechatronics, and apply Arctic Silver III. We'll see how it goes. I can always upgrade later. Hey, anyone know if socket A Athlon heatsinks will fit Intel Socket 478? (Sorry, haven't researched that one yet.) If that's the case, I've got another Alpha 8045 coming out of one of my systems for it.

New systems/rebuilds financed mainly through "travel pay" from my adventure in Operation Iraqi Freedom.

(A little spam? HEADS UP - parts from my present systems will soon be posted for sale at the Deal Depot & Trading Post. Preview: KX7333-R, volt-modded!; AXP 2000; KR7A-R; AXP 1900; PC2700 DRAM - Samsung, TwinMOS; WD BB series hard drives.....)

Leo

Reply with Quote

Leonardo

Buzzwinkle the Moose FTW

14,843 Posts

22 Jul 2003, 12:31pm

Two Rebuilds Up and Running Fast

Check out my signature - rebuilds nearly completed. Just looking for another Radeon 9500 Pro (or flashable 9500) for system 2.

Preliminary comments:

1. Both were relatively easy to build. Both were fairly easy to configure. The edge here for ease of software/OS setup is the AMD system. The IC7 system was relatively easy to setup, except that I had to learn BIOS settings for "On-chip" SATA. NF7-Barton was rock solid stable from the moment OS was installed and motherboard drivers were installed. Intel was equally stable after minor tweaks.

2. Both systems' OS installation was without a clean install, as so-- OS install; remove/uninstall nearly all drivers and devices; shut down system; disassemble; rebuild; reset CMOS; start-boot to CD; install WinXP in "Repair" mode.

3. Geil RAM performs exactly as advertised - CAS 2.5, 6-3-3. It's running perfectly in the NF7 box, and is running famously in the Intel system with Hyperthreading and dual channel enabled.

4. Bugs - NF7 has NONE whatsoever; IC7 3.3 voltage fluctuates from 3.1 to 3.7; IC7's hardware monitoring software (both Motherboard Monitor 5 and Hardware Doctor) report CPU core temperature 30+*C higher than BIOS reports.

5. OK, the BIG question. PERFORMANCE? Completely unempirically with no tests or benchmarks to back up my statement.... I give the edge to the Intel Canterwood system. It is simply fast, fast, fast. The NF7 is not far behind it, though.

6. Dual channel goodness (Intel) - running two instances of Folding@Home. One instance is as a service, run by one channel (virtual "CPU 1"); the other instance in normal mode by "CPU 0".

I will be posting a separate thread concerning the IC7's 3.3 apparent voltage fluctuation under the Motherboards forum.

No overclocking....yet. That should prove to be quite fun.

Fixed whine of the WD800JBs. Pretty simple, I merely affixed felt pads, the kind used on kitchen drawers and cabinets, onto the hard drives' surfaces that come into contact with the Chieftec's drive cages.

My hat is off to both Intel and AMD. To Intel - finally a CPU-chipset combo that really lives up to the hype; to AMD - nVidea - excellent engineering that is very competitive.

This was my first Intel build. I've always said that I'd go with whoever had the best bang for the buck. Intel was slightly more expensive, but not by much considering I'm using the stock, $3 Intel heatsink fan unit. And, oh yes - why can't AMD come up with a heatsink retention mechanism as simple and easy to use as the P4's?

Leo

PS - Thank you to Ageek, for helping me understand the Hyperthreading-Dual Channel workings and Windows interaction with it.

Reply with Quote

Omega65

EPoX Evangelist!

2,891 Posts

22 Jul 2003, 12:57pm

Re: Two Rebuilds Up and Running Fast

Leonardo said
Fixed whine of the WD800JBs. Pretty simple, I merely affixed felt pads, the kind used on kitchen drawers and cabinets, onto the hard drives' surfaces that come into contact with the Chieftec's drive cages.

THANKS! - never considered that.......

Reply with Quote

Straight_Man

Playing with Virtual Painter

3,716 Posts

22 Jul 2003, 4:00pm

Clear GE silicone works too. Real old drives had mountings made so that the holes were rubber grommetted-- sometimes with threads inside grommet in an insert. Silicone will also deaden vibes.

Two choices if you use silicone-- let the silicone cure with machine screw in place, unscrew machine screw when cured, or let the silicone cure after mounting. It then acts as a vibration deadener.

Reply with Quote

TheLostSwede

Where's the ****ing beers?

3,220 Posts

22 Jul 2003, 6:17pm

Here�s the smartest mod i have ever seen and it kills ANY harddrive vibrations.

Attached Thumbnails

Click image for larger version

Name: hdstrap2[1].jpg
Views: 22
Size: 193.1 KB
ID: 1606

Reply with Quote

		Icrontic Forums > Tech: Hardware > General Hardware
Recommendations Please for Two PC Rebuilds

Jump to

This Thread	Search this Thread
Print Email	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

Username
Password	Forgot?
Remember me