Sign in or Register (it’s quick!)

Forgot?
 
Reply to Discussion Options
Outther
Hypothetical being from Space
Outther
27 Posts
27 Aug 2003, 4:15am

Question RAID 1 ATA assistence

Maby you can suggest a better option. I am going to build a modded box (conversation piece) for a local Doctors Office.

Beacuse it will hold all patient data and vital info they want Raid 0 mirroring.

Due to most new Raid boards have SATA raid and not the real SATA benifit IE 150 VS 133 Mbps I am opting for ATA 133 raid system. Cheaper basically

I am looking at the Epox EP-8KRA2+

Is there a better board that will support a 333 FSB and ATA RAID?

I am open to any suggestions. If we were talking 266FSB I would go with the KT333 SOYO Dragon Ultra Platnum I love mine

Thanks
__________________ /\/\od Artist & Alien aficionado
Reply with Quote
Outther edited : 27 Aug 2003 at 12:23pm .
primesuspect
The Icrontic Guy
primesuspect
29,322 Posts
27 Aug 2003, 4:19am
Outther said
Beacuse it will hold all patient data and vital info they want Raid 0 mirroring.
Whoa.. This is the first problem that I see:

RAID 0 IS NOT REDUNDANT - Raid 0 is not mirrored - it is striped. It's high performance, but no data backup whatsoever. In fact, it's doubly dangerous because if one of two drives fails, all data is lost.

You want RAID 1 if you're only using two drives. RAID 1 is a slow performer - figure drive speed minus a tad bit for RAID overhead. If you want a very fast, but redundant array, you need RAID10, which requires at LEAST four drives. Two striped drives, mirrored onto the other two.
__________________ Subscribe for the FULL Icrontic Experience | Sponsor Icrontic for a day! Troll your friends!
Reply with Quote
Outther
Hypothetical being from Space
Outther
27 Posts
27 Aug 2003, 5:11am
Yes you are correct I meant RAID 1 mirroring not RAID 0 stripping.

Thanks for your assistance in clearing that up that mistake.

So does anyone have a better suggestion on Mobo's for this App? Thanks in advance
Reply with Quote
Outther edited : 27 Aug 2003 at 5:16am .
Creep
Icrontic Posting Maniac
Creep
415 Posts
27 Aug 2003, 6:43am
That board should be as good as any others out there.

btw I love my KT400 Black Dragon Ultra
__________________

My Heatware

Reply with Quote
Geeky1
No comment.
Geeky1
7,972 Posts
27 Aug 2003, 6:52am
For basic functionality, any board from a decent manufacturer is more than sufficient.
__________________ -MCCCXXXVII
"Ignorance is forgivable. Stupidity is inexcusable."

Resident Dual CPU Addict: 3 working duallies, 2 more in the parts drawer, and looking to add an Opteron dually to that list as soon as I can find a good motherboard...
Reply with Quote
Shorty
Sniping teh enterpwise!
Shorty
9,678 Posts
27 Aug 2003, 8:04am
Welcome to Short-Media Outter

Tsk.. where are these guys manners? anyway..

There are some hit and miss things going on with the KT600 platform from what's been written by a few who are trying them out.

If you are after an standard ATA133 setup, then getting a slightly older but revised, stable as a rock board is no problem Just grab a $30 Highpoint 372 card. Id actually recommend this because this is a biz rig, not a gaming, tweaking setup.

Im using the ABIT nForce2 NF7-S, which only has SATA but a PCI highpoint card gives me as good performance as onboard. There was an article (which I can't find damnit) published eons ago, that noted the differences between onboard & PCI. They were a mute point because they were so close

Buy for the needs for the job which I feel in this case is go with what you know and trust + a $30/$40 PCI highpoint 372 or 374
__________________ I am a twit... follow me... @s8nftw
Reply with Quote
Outther
Hypothetical being from Space
Outther
27 Posts
27 Aug 2003, 12:22pm
Thanks for all the replys

I had not even considered a daughter card. Maby I will look into this. I guess it was just one of those "if you can get it onboard why pay extra" issues. Kinda like buying a USB 2.0 card

Kinda reminds me of the days when the IDE controller was a daughter card. That going onboard was a big improvement

Outther
Reply with Quote
Mt_Goat
Relentless Pursuit
Mt_Goat
4,973 Posts
27 Aug 2003, 11:12pm
For RAID-1 I would just do software RAID through Win2K or if you'r using XP (don't know why you would use that for buisness). There is just one real pitfall to the RAID-1 approach though and it is a big one. Anything that you put on one will go on the other automaticly (good thing) but anything else like a virus, worm or anything else not wanted will go on it also (bad thing). I would highly recomend a good backup utility that could be set to automaticly backup the changes at the end of the day when the system is shut down. Just my $.02.
__________________ I met 2 woman in a bar and they said that every good politician needs to start their career with a scandal. Then one of them told me that they were the best of friends and did everything together! So mount up cowboy!
This is a true story that happened in Bowie, Maryland last winter.
Reply with Quote
Spinner
Getting it done!
Spinner
5,003 Posts
28 Aug 2003, 12:55am
Correct me if I'm wrong, but Serillel2 adapters should also do the trick right? They allow PATA drives (standard ATA) to run on a SATA controller. You could say get a board like the NF7-S v2.0, or any other relatively modern board (with SATA), and just pick up some Serillel2 adapters, I think at least one should be included with most SATA boards anyway, so you may just have to buy one, though I'm not sure. Just a thought.

Here are some threads you might find some relevant information in:
http://www.short-media.com/forum/sho...&threadid=2889
http://www.short-media.com/forum/sho...&threadid=2464
http://www.short-media.com/forum/sho...&threadid=2642

Oh yea, and by the way... WELCOME TO SHORT-MEDIA Outther!
__________________

Wedding Band - Junction 2
Reply with Quote
Preacher
Contentious Cajun of the Cloth
Preacher
1,286 Posts

» Subscriber

28 Aug 2003, 2:34am
Wouldn't another advantage of the PCI RAID daughter card be easy portability to a new motherboard? I know when I switched motherboards the RAID controller changed from Highpoint to Promise and I had to rebuild my array. Luckily, I had everything backed up prior. The daughter card should eliminate that problem, especially if you keep your OS, applications, and data on different partitions.
Reply with Quote
Outther
Hypothetical being from Space
Outther
27 Posts
28 Aug 2003, 2:46am
Thanks for all the input. I will consider all carefully. Ultimatly it will be me telling this guy hey hear are your options and I reccomend the following but you chose what you want to pay for.

Thanks Again
Reply with Quote
Go Back   Icrontic Forums > Tech: Hardware > Storage
Reload this Page RAID 0 ATA assistence
Jump to
This Thread Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Today's Posts - Mark All Read - Contact Us - Icrontic.com - Archive - Top

Current time: 4:00am (GMT)
Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Get Vanilla Forums instead. Trust me.