Promise TX4 vs Silcon Image

To talk on Icrontic, just register!

It only takes 30 seconds.

Have an account? Sign in:

Reply to Discussion

Options

Spider

New to the neighborhood

4 Posts

24 Sep 2003, 12:44am

Promise TX4 vs Silcon Image

I'm currently using a Silcon Image (v2) IDE RAID controller card. It's hooked to two 40gig WD 8mb Cache drives. I just picked up a a Promise Tx4 (older one) which is a 4-channel card. If I still only used the 2 drives would there be any speed benefit in switching to this card?

I also have a WD 80g 8mb Drive. Would running 2 of these be faster then the 2 40g?

I also thought about picking up another 40g & running a 3 disk array.

Any thoughts would be appreciated.

Current ATTO Scores:
.5 11k/11k
1 2k/21k
2 15k/38k
4 34k/53k
8 56k/61k
16 65k/62k
32 72k/67k
64 75k/73k
128 76k/74k
256 75k/76k
512 75k/76k
1024 76k/76k

Reply with Quote

primesuspect

The Icrontic Guy

27,798 Posts

24 Sep 2003, 12:58am

I've heard that the SI is a tib faster, So I don't think it's worth switching. I've been using Promise controllers since they started, and I've never liked them. All of the RAIDs I've ever lost have been on Promise controllers. I would say to stick with the SI.

__________________ "I offer my genius to the world, all I ask is you pick up my expenses"

Reply with Quote

Mt_Goat

Relentless Pursuit

4,920 Posts

24 Sep 2003, 3:06am

Stick with the SI as it is faster. You could probably tweak your array with the Latency Guide at the end of this thread (last post). As far as an 80 being faster; nope, it is the same drive but with 2 platters so the density is the same and that is where the difference in speed would come into play, but not here.

__________________ I met a woman in a bar and she asked if she could take me home. I replied that I was better than that. So she asked if she could take me to a nice restraunt for dinner then go to a fancy hotel for the night and I said OK.

Reply with Quote

Spider

New to the neighborhood

4 Posts

24 Sep 2003, 3:20am

Thanks for the input guys.

I have tried tweaking the latency. from 64 all the up to 248. I never really saw much of a difference. I also tried the Breeze latency patch and that seemed to make things slower.

How do my Atto scores look?

I have an A7v333 v1.02, 2500+@2255, 1gig pc2700 (512x2)

Reply with Quote

primesuspect

The Icrontic Guy

27,798 Posts

24 Sep 2003, 6:35am

Those attos are pretty good....

Reply with Quote

Spider

New to the neighborhood

4 Posts

24 Sep 2003, 1:06pm

Hey guys thanks for all the help and input. I think I'll stick with the SI card and sell the Promise for what I paid for it.

Reply with Quote

		Icrontic Forums > Tech: Hardware > Storage
Promise TX4 vs Silcon Image

Jump to

This Thread	Search this Thread
Print Email	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

Username
Password	Forgot?
Remember me