Sign in or Register (it’s quick!)

Forgot?
bothered
pondering and wandering along
bothered
4,548 Posts

Gromacs slow.

Why are gromacs so slow? I mean it's just maths. What do they do differantly that takes three times as long to complete?
__________________ Abit IP35Dark Raider:Core 2 Duo 2.66GHz:4Gb OCZ Ram:MSI 8800GTS:3 HDD(240Gb):Pioneer 108: DVD:Camera,Lexmark AIO printer scanner:xp pro sp2: Understanding Wife.
[folding_sig1]
shwaip
elaborate bot
shwaip
6,246 Posts
They are not necessarily doing the same kind of math. What can you do faster:

3x4
or
3.1124 x 4.214

Also, they may even be doing more math in a given frame.
__________________
Anyone who wants dropbox, please use my referral link
muddocktor
Wandering about
muddocktor
6,260 Posts
It all depends on the individual work unit you are working on too. There are some 21 and 24 point Gromacs out there and there also are some 230 pointers too. Before Stanford reworked the points on Tinker work, the Gromacs work was the best units to get for points production but when Stanford switched benchmark machines to the P4 2.8 from the Celeron 500, the Tinker points worth went up a whole bunch. That is due to the P4's weak native FPU unit and Tinker not using any SSE or SSE2 optimizations, which is weaker than even the old Celeron's or P3's FPU unit. Since the Athlon and Duron processors have a much superior native FPU unit they are much more efficient at non-optimized Tinker wu's, which makes them produce a higher points/hour on Tinker wus.
__________________ I have some computers running Seti@Home.
bothered
pondering and wandering along
bothered
4,548 Posts
It's like 230+ tinker, 24 hours. 230+ gromac, 2 1\2 days.
Oh well, it's the work that's important. Is there any way to make sure eyes only gets all gromacs?
muddocktor
Wandering about
muddocktor
6,260 Posts
There's no real way to specify only Gromacs or only Tinker work, unfortunately, and I wish there was so I could keep the Tinkers off my P4 rigs.

One thing that comes to mind on your time disparity bothered, is that it almost looks like the folding client isn't using SSE on your machine with Gromacs work. What client are you running (graphical or console) and are you using the -forceasm or -forcesse switch on the shortcut you are starting the client with?
bothered
pondering and wandering along
bothered
4,548 Posts
graphical v4. I think I set -forceasm when I set it up but it was ages ago and I'm not 100% sure. I don't 'start' the client, it runs whenever the PC's on.

edit,
just checked, -advmethods -forceasm are what's set.
EyesOnly
S_M convict...err convert
EyesOnly
1,479 Posts
Is there any way to make sure eyes only gets all gromacs?
Hey i heard that.


There's no real way to specify only Gromacs or only Tinker work, unfortunately, and I wish there was so I could keep the Tinkers off my P4 rigs.

One thing that comes to mind on your time disparity bothered, is that it almost looks like the folding client isn't using SSE on your machine with Gromacs work. What client are you running (graphical or console) and are you using the -forceasm or -forcesse switch on the shortcut you are starting the client with?
I too wish there was some way so i could get only tinkers. I'm running the console installed by firedaemon with no switches. Someone said a while back that they weren't needed so i didn't add any. Considering that this is the second post i read today where bothered makes up for his name and wish that i slow down indicates that i'm doing something right.

Hopfully i wont see any more of those 20 minutes frame times. I hate them.
__________________ Wanna help fight cancer. Download Folding @ Home now.click here for more info
[folding_sig1]



My blog - in swedish
mmonnin
Veteran Icrontian
mmonnin
10,545 Posts
Gromacs do like 3x more work, as in data calculations, than tinkers do. Thus the time difference. Also one thing, it depends on the CPU. If its a P4 then it should be about the same times. An athlon, how ever will kick ass with tinkers.
__________________ Stanford Team Stats_____________Team Short-Media
Statsman Team Stats______________EOC Team Stats
witenoiz
Time out of balance!
witenoiz
326 Posts
See this link from Missileman http://www.short-media.com/forum/showthread.php?t=17891 If I have a unit that shuts down improperly, I alway restart it and then shut it down with Ctrl + C and then start it again. I keep this very simple - always on the desktop - never use flags - always move low pointers to the slowest box. I have had some success with this arrangement. Jack
__________________
"Somewhere, something incredible is waiting to be known." Carl Sagan, US astronomer
Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
P4s Superior with Gromacs...or So We Thought Leonardo Folding@Home 8 14 Jul 2004 7:43pm
Double Gromacs Again - Unbelievable! Leonardo Folding@Home 13 7 Jun 2004 4:21pm
Radeon 9800XT not working correctly (Very slow) Bond007uk General Hardware 21 3 Jun 2004 3:24am
um...anyone know whats up? fatcat Folding@Home 29 11 Feb 2004 2:58am
Gromacs on Linux on a P4, finally running right! Straight_Man Folding@Home 0 22 Nov 2003 1:18am

Go Back   Icrontic Forums > Community > Folding@Home
Jump to
This Thread Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search


Current time: 3:47am (GMT)
Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Get Vanilla Forums instead. Trust me.