Is it possible to run F@h in ancient processors?

EyesOnlyEyesOnly Sweden New
edited February 2004 in Folding@Home
I want to run fah on a pentium1 processor. What should i do to get it running as fast as possible without errors. And don't tell me to get a new comp because if i could afford it i would do it in a heartbeat but for now i'm stuck with this.

This comp will do nothing but fold as i have a p2 for other stuff. And i would like to get my p2 folding as well since it has done it before then stopped. Not sure why.
«1

Comments

  • mmonninmmonnin Centreville, VA
    edited November 2003
    When configuring the clients make sure it will get genomes. They dont have a time limit. A P1 will NOT finish a tinker or gromac before the deadline and will slow the project down. Set the P2 up the same way. It might be able to finish tinkers in time if all it was doind was folding but you are using it.
  • EnverexEnverex Worcester, UK Icrontian
    edited November 2003
    When you run the configure option make sure you select gah, not fah or auto, that should give you genomes....

    Also don't bother using the -forceasm as the chip doesn't support any advanced features.

    NS
  • t1rhinot1rhino Toronto
    edited November 2003
    Actually, I have 2 P200s that fold gromacs and return them in the alotted time. :)
    Mind you, it's about 1 gro WU a week. :D
  • EyesOnlyEyesOnly Sweden New
    edited November 2003
    Mind you, it's about 1 gro WU a week.

    At least it's something. Haven't installed it yet but will let you now soon how it goes. Thanks t1rhino your post made me more confident about doing this. Glad i'm not the only one with a slow comp. :D
  • mmonninmmonnin Centreville, VA
    edited November 2003
    But at that slow its not really worth the electricity...unless its the offices.;)
  • edited November 2003
    I think it's worth it for EyesOnly to get a cool sig. :D
  • primesuspectprimesuspect Beepin n' Boopin Detroit, MI Icrontian
    edited November 2003
    Of course it's worth it, mmonnin!

    I have in my arsenal a couple of dogs, but they do fold, and they do generate points, and they do further the goals of the project.. A celly 333, and a p166.. EyesOnly, it's worth it, but make sure they are getting genomes only, as they will not return the tinkers or gromacs within the allotted time.
  • WuGgaRoOWuGgaRoO Not in the shower Icrontian
    edited November 2003
    damn.... a p1 folding...i though id never see neone try that out..what about my 33mhz chip...that worth it?
  • CyrixInsteadCyrixInstead Stoke-on-Trent, England Icrontian
    edited November 2003
    I've been running folding on a P150 for over a year now. It's still chugging away merrily.

    ~Cyrix
  • edited November 2003
    I've been looking at the gromacs I've been folding and the time limits have all been 14 days.
    I get my electricity free so if I had an older machine to dedicate to folding (even at one wu every 10 days) it'd still be worth it to just get that little bit of boost to my score :D
  • primesuspectprimesuspect Beepin n' Boopin Detroit, MI Icrontian
    edited November 2003
    Any processor, no matter how slow, can fold Genomes. It is worth it, it helps the project no matter what.
  • kanezfankanezfan
    installs on my atari 800xl

    >: no port for atari? what gives man?
    sunny south florida Icrontian
    edited November 2003
    installs on my atari 800xl

    >: no port for atari? what gives man?
  • EyesOnlyEyesOnly Sweden New
    edited November 2003
    Thanks for the support and yes electricity would be needed but i allready keep this comp running most of the days anyway. A sig would be really nice. WuGgaRoO you should give your chip a try. Who knows. If i hade just kept my C64.:D

    My computers refuse to talk to each other so the network isn't working. :sad2: Will fix it asap then start folding.
  • EyesOnlyEyesOnly Sweden New
    edited November 2003
    It's up and running. After spending many hours fixing, rebooting, threating, and installing i've finaly done it. And realised that p1:s suck at folding. Strangely though the cpu is running at 89 Mhz not 166 Mhz as i set it on. Must have made a mistake. I'll let it cool over night and fix it.
  • EyesOnlyEyesOnly Sweden New
    edited November 2003
    Ok now i'm throwing in the towel. The network isn't working AGAIN and the program can't download new work. Also the stats in Em3 was reset when i turned of the comp so now i'm back at 0. I've reinstalled win 98 three times in 2 day and now i'm done with this. Luckily this site seems to bring value in other ways than foldning to so until later this is me signing out of folding.
  • mmonninmmonnin Centreville, VA
    edited November 2003
    Did you ever get a genome? They dont take that long on the slower computers. Still maybe several days.

    Of course EM3 will start over when the computer is turned off.
  • EyesOnlyEyesOnly Sweden New
    edited November 2003
    It's no use. And no i didn't. after i changed the settings to give me genoms the network didn't work, which is strange because when i turned of the comp everything was ok. Also when it started it didn't find the harddrive. I put in a disk with partionmagic and it to failed to find the disk. i then turned of the comp and checked all connetions in it. thinking that the powercable for the harddrive might be the cause i switched it to another free cable.

    when i started the comp it found the harddrive but the comp could not connect to the internet when windows was loaded. my other comp was able to connect to the second one with realVNC and control it and nothing was wrong at this side. i reinstalled all network drivers and protocolls, ran the setup small office network or Lan wizard than gave up when it didn't work.

    i really don't feel like reinstalling win98 again just so i can wait 2 weeks before i finish a wu, and that's only if i run it 24\7, so i'm hoping that you will find my expertise in computers valuable in other parts in this site. i might cool down during the night before i log on here again so if you can talk me into continiu folding i might. But i still why the network only works sometimes. Sorry for the long post.
  • drasnordrasnor Starship Operator Hawthorne, CA Icrontian
    edited November 2003
    I ran folding on my IBM PC300GL (Pentium 200 MMX) for awhile, it could usually do a tinker a week. Haven't tried it with gromacs yet, but I bet it would work. I upgraded the processor to a Pentium 233 MMX, so it's rippin' up those Jade Falcons at MW2.

    -drasnor :fold:
  • EyesOnlyEyesOnly Sweden New
    edited November 2003
    I really thought that i had a strong will but i didn't. all it took was 1 post and i was back at folding. :banghead: The comp found internet :confused: and apperently i was supposed to start this comp after i started the folding comp. :doh:

    The cpu speed is giving me a headache. When i set it to what i thought was 166 mhz it according to Em3 ran at 89 mhz. When i set it to 150 mhz it ran at 89 mhz. This morning when i set it to 133 mhz it ran at 189 mhz. :confused2 :confused2 :eek3: :sad2: Can someone please tell me what's going on. Sure i'm glad that the speed increased but it feels like i'm not in control here.

    BTW do genomes count as wu's in the stats because i'm running that now.:confused::wave:
  • drasnordrasnor Starship Operator Hawthorne, CA Icrontian
    edited November 2003
    EyesOnly had this to say
    Can someone please tell me what's going on. Sure i'm glad that the speed increased but it feels like i'm not in control here.

    BTW do genomes count as wu's in the stats because i'm running that now.:confused::wave:
    Don't trust your BIOS, download CPUID or CPU-Z (use google to find). Some switches control bus speed, and others control your multiplier. It's a lot of trial-and-error. BTW, if your processor supports bigger multipliers than it's rated for, use them. My experience is that Pentiums will overclock to anything within their range of operation (200-233MHz tops) given decent cooling.

    AFAIK Genomes count toward your WU total.

    -drasnor :fold:
  • EyesOnlyEyesOnly Sweden New
    edited November 2003
    Thanks drasnor. I tried cpuid but it didn't tell me much. Here's what it said.

    processor family: 5
    model: 2
    stepping: c

    It also said that it was an genuin intel pentium which it is. i can't acces the harddrive on the other computer though so i can't use CPU-Z. I don't now what's wrong. The computer ran fine for many hours but some hours ago realvnc crashed. i restarted it but couldn't connect to the folding comp. After plugging in the monitor i noticed that it had frozen and that the harddrive activity led shone all the time. Upon reboting it stopped after post and said that the harddrive was loast asking me to insert a disk.

    I've tried several reboots without succes. please help.
  • drasnordrasnor Starship Operator Hawthorne, CA Icrontian
    edited November 2003
    Download an imager for Drive Fitness Test (DFT), image it to a floppy, and try booting with that. It'll tell you whether or not your drive is dead. There are also a few other free diagnostic disks floating around the Internet if you need something more comprehensive.

    If you're somewhat Linux competent and you can get it to boot from a CD-ROM, try booting it with a Knoppix CD.

    BTW, this is happening to one of my other older machines, but I can't work on it at the moment since it's about 100 miles away right now.

    -drasnor :fold:
  • EyesOnlyEyesOnly Sweden New
    edited November 2003
    The comp did the exact same thing two days ago. yesterday i switched powercable and set the cpu at 150 mhz and then it ran just fine. i think that heat could be the issue since the distance between the heatzink and the harddrive is less then 3 centimeters. it's not a standard case BTW so i can't move the harddrive to a better location.
  • EyesOnlyEyesOnly Sweden New
    edited November 2003
    Ok now i'm really in trouble and this time it's not the cpu that's causing it. The folding computer (which used to be a server) is supposed to go trough 2 bioses. 1 on the motherbord (post) and 1 on the scsi card. But it doesn't go trough the one on the scsi card which makes me belive that the card is broken. I've checked all connection and the card is seated properly so it must be broken. Looks like i'll have to wait untill i can get new parts for it.

    I can't fold with this computer because i use it to much so there's no free power to use for folding. oh well thanks for the help anyway.

    *EyesOnly heads for the babes thread while it's still there*
  • drasnordrasnor Starship Operator Hawthorne, CA Icrontian
    edited November 2003
    If you've got SCSI in there it could be about a thousand things wrong including adapter failure.

    http://www.scsifaq.com

    -drasnor :fold:
  • EyesOnlyEyesOnly Sweden New
    edited November 2003
    If you've got SCSI in there it could be about a thousand things wrong including adapter failure.

    I don't think i know but thanks for the cheering up. I'll have a look at the faq tomorrow.
  • EyesOnlyEyesOnly Sweden New
    edited February 2004
    It's time to revive this old thread with a guide to those who fold on slow machines.

    Here how to do it. Follow the guidelines given in this forum as usual. I used firedaemon to run the nononsens commandline client of fah as a service and electron microscope (or em3) to monitor it. To avoid biting your nails of wondering if it will finish before the deadline fold as genome@home (or gah) because it doesn't have any deadlines but the points you get still counts as regular points. Or so i've been told. Will know for sure in a couple of days. :tongue:

    Now the important part. The one that i failed back in november. Don't look at em3 every 30 minutes or so wondering why it isn't moving much (it's just slow and you're slowing it down even more by forcing it to show the stats all the time) and don't worry if you get a "Time per frame problem". You get it because em3 thinks that you will finish in a certain time but then you use the computer or em3 misscalculated the time and finds that the frame isn't finished. I thought that i had a serious problem on my hands and the fact that i then used an even slower P1 instead of the P2 i'm using now lead me to believe that folding is impossible on slow computers. That is not the case.

    Whenever you get a time per frame problem it simply means that em3 can't tell you when the frame will be finished BUT FAH IS WORKING JUST FINE. Just look at fah:s log in em3 and you'll see that it's still doing it's thing even though em3 appears to be halted. It will show something like

    [07:22:23] [SPG] Designing protein sequence 13 of 30
    [07:43:14] [SPG] 10.0
    [08:10:29] [SPG] 20.0
    [08:29:37] [SPG] 30.0
    [08:48:13] [SPG] 40.0
    [09:11:28] [SPG] 50.0
    [09:46:48] [SPG] 60.0
    [10:23:00] [SPG] 70.0
    [11:07:58] [SPG] 80.0
    [11:47:46] [SPG] 90.0
    [12:20:40] [SPG] 100.0
    [12:20:40] [SPG] Writing current.xyz
    [12:20:42] [SPG] Sequence 13 completed:

    and then move on to the next frame. I have no idea what SPG means but it appears to be what percents of the frame that has been finished. That log entry was from the last frame my computer finished. It's currently working itself through frame 14 of 30 but unless i rap this up it will finish the wu before i'm finished typing. :D

    In favor of em3 would be that it does "learn" when a frame will be finished after a couple of frames but sometimes failes completely. Yesterday a frame in em3 finished in about a minute but then i got that problem again. Hours later the frame was finished in fah and em3 moved on to the next.

    I really wish that i hadn't had to write this but those few who folds in this forum and have slow machines don't use them as much as i do and don't have any problems like this. Therefor i had to discover this for myself. Hopefully this can make others thinking about folding sure that they can fold but not expect many wu:s per week or even month.

    Oh and one last thing. You might be wondering if my computer is slower now. The answer is NO. I do not even notice that fah is running. Sure the cpu is running at 100 % and some ram is used but not so much that it's slowing things down. I notice that there are many member that has a few points but doesn't appear to be folding because the points isn't increasing. Well if you're not folding because you think that your computer will be slow or that it can't be done you're wrong. It does take a while to set up but then you can just forget about it. As long as you can boot and run programs you can fold. :fold:

    Sorry for the long post. If i think of something else i'll add it.
  • profdlpprofdlp The Holy City Of Westlake, Ohio
    edited February 2004
    That's a nice post, Eyes! Glad to hear you stuck with it. Your advice will be a big help (and hopefully an inspiration) to others in the same situation.

    Now, when are you getting the fancy Folding sig? :thumbsup::fold: :sweflag:
  • EyesOnlyEyesOnly Sweden New
    edited February 2004
    In about 3 to 7 days. It's impossible to say when since i'm using the computer quite a lot and when each frame finishes i get a different time. But i'm getting there.

    BTW i must have messed up somewhere because the fahlog says that it's working on frame 14 of 30 but em2 says that i'm on 12 of 30. It must have missed a frame somewhere. Well at least fah is working even though the monitoring is off a bit. I'll try FAH LogStats and see if it's any good. Maybe it can fix this.
  • mmonninmmonnin Centreville, VA
    edited February 2004
    Hmm I've never known EM3 to do that. Its pretty good at that. Nice post.
Sign In or Register to comment.