The Mandalorian

So I bit the bullet and got Disney+ so I could watch this tonight.

I liked it, decent job building the world up, pacing was a bit quick but does a good job. Nice bit of bait to grab you at the end and keep you coming back. I'm in.

Just wish it was a bit longer per episode, not sure if I'm into the music yet either.

I watched ESB after it. Damn it looks good in 4K, Lucas meddling be damned.

Comments

  • AlexDeGruvenAlexDeGruven Wut? Meechigan

    I really liked it. They did a great job fitting it in the universe in some indeterminate time. I'm assuming we'll get more context as time goes on. All I can see is that we're post Jedi at this point.


    Also: SO CUTE OMG

  • I loved the first episode. It's a space western.

    One of the most compelling things about Star Wars is that there are so many opportunities to tell original stories. Sometimes they crossover with the more popular lore, but sometimes they don't need to. I think that is the opportunity here, give me the intergalactic version of the man with no name.

    Also: They are gonna sell a ton of those things, OMG!!

  • primesuspectprimesuspect Beepin n' Boopin Detroit, MI

    I'll probably subscribe once all 8 episodes are out

  • I am thrilled they are going to trickle out a week at a time. I've tried the binge watching thing. I've done it with Stranger Things, I binged Breaking Bad in a couple weeks well after it was off the air, I'm currently doing American God's.

    Frankly, getting a story all at once kills that anticipation of what may come next. It ruins an integral part of what watching a television series is about. That communal water cooler thing where you watch an episode and then discuss what you liked and what might be coming next. When you swallow it all in one big chunk you lose that.

  • primesuspectprimesuspect Beepin n' Boopin Detroit, MI

    Nah, I'm good. I don't watch TV normally; I can go months without watching anything. I see it as an interruption to my normal routine so I want it to be worthwhile. When I sit down to watch something, I want to consume it all, enjoy it, and go back to my regular routine.

    MAGIC
  • AlexDeGruvenAlexDeGruven Wut? Meechigan

    I see both sides of the equation. The anticipation of the next episode in a serial is what Television has been all about since almost inception. But at the same time, it's also great to be able to sit down and watch the entire story at your own pace and not have to wait.

    I think there's an art to crafting a series to fit one or the other.

    Bosch was great at putting together an 8+ hour story and breaking it up into manageable chunks that could be watched in groups, as a whole, or one at a time.

    Stranger Things, I feel, fits the weekly serial mode better.

    I feel like The Mandalorian fits the serial mode as well. Not so much a cliffhanger as a note to say "Tune in next week!".

  • One issue with the trickle release method for those that enjoy a good TV binge session is that it's nearly impossible to avoid spoilers in the internet age. Like I'm being super sweet as I usually am and not spoiling and being careful not to spoil any major details for anyone, but hey, 99% of the internet isn't as soft and sensitive to the entertainment needs of others as I am.

    The second episode was dope. It looks and sounds like Star Wars. I think they are doing a brilliant job of balancing practical effects and creature creations with CG. The CG isn't quite big budget film quality but it's pretty good. Some of the sounds in the second episode, it's so Star Wars... I know that's a silly thing to critique but it just feels like it belongs in that place that your imagined as a child. It's tone is universal, I imagine some older jaded fans are going to hate it for being a little too cute or campy in places, but I have always enjoyed that component of Star Wars.

    Point is, it's good. May the force be with those who wait to avoid spoilers.

  • AlexDeGruvenAlexDeGruven Wut? Meechigan

    Couple of really great moments in Ep2. Very good stuff.


    I'm going to start using "I have spoken" on my kids.

  • jj Sterling Heights, MI

    LOL, yeah I'm doing that too. Brush your teeth...I have spoken.

  • jj Sterling Heights, MI

    I'm really liking the show so far. It's got that star wars feel, and it doesn't have a comic relief character. I would recommend it.

  • ThraxThrax Professional Shill, Watch Slut, Mumble Hivemind Drone Austin, TX

    I'm enjoying the show so far as well.

  • jj Sterling Heights, MI

    I do think the music is very campy and sitcom TV style. Also, now that I have watched a few episodes it's becoming very obvious what's going to happen in the final episode. I think all the people he has met in each episode will come back and help Mando is some way...This is the way...I have spoken. If not, then there is starting to be no continuity between episodes. This last episode was kinda boring, and didn't add much to the Mandilorian story. A filler episode maybe.

  • SonorousSonorous F@H Fanatic US

    You have to remember that once the overall story and setting is established in the first few episodes, shows will take a few episodes and use them to develop the characters further. For example in episode 5 we see Mando starting to shift some of his major characteristics. Before he started helping baby Yoda I don't believe he would have even considered helping that kid out with his bounty. But Mando is different now and no longer just a cold and effective bounty hunter. I think we will see one or two more development episodes before things start to resolve.

Sign In or Register to comment.