Motherboard ok? ASUS P4800 SE

edited May 2004 in Hardware
I have been looking at a new motherboard i had suggestions about Abit IA7 and IC7 but was concerned about the noise from the Northbridge Fan, and the temp of the CPU being over 50c just sitting in the BIOS!

I like the look of this board P4P800S

However the one i have seen is a p4p800 SE and it is £53 at overclockers

Just one thing confuses my about these boards, what is the difference between 'Springdale' and Canterwood'?

And most importantly i have a P4 2.4Ghz 533fsb 'Northwood' Cpu will a Northwood cpu work in this motherboard?

The intel site also states about two types of 2.4Ghz CPU a 2.40A and a 2.40B, how do i find out which is mine?

I am only upgrading because my brand spanking new 9800XT will not run properly in my current mobo (have tried everything from different drivers, agp speeds, no fast writes, still slow and crashes, i does work have tried on friends machine)

Need a good motherboard that works with my CPU and max £80 (GBP) cost. Must have good CPU temps too. Currenty my cpu is 37c idle and 55c when running games like Far Cry.

Comments

  • LeonardoLeonardo Wake up and smell the glaciers Eagle River, Alaska Icrontian
    edited May 2004
    The IS7 and IC7 respectively employ the Intel I865 and I875 chipsets, which are respectively the 'Springdale' and 'Canterwood'. These chipsets are optimized for the P4 800 MHz (Series 'C') CPUs, but are also backwards compatible with 533MHz FSB P4s. I can personally attest to the excellence of the IC7. Bar none, it's the best motherboard I've ever owned. Scuttlebut is that the IS7 boards perform almost as well, or as well as the IC7s.

    Your 2.4 Northwood would run well in any of the Abit or Asus boards you mentioned.

    Did you have a thread here about your your video card problems? Perhaps it is not a motherboard problem, but a power supply unit problem?

    The motherboard will have little or nothing to do with the actual temperatures of your CPU - that is determined by the speed, thereby power consumption/waste heat of the CPU, the quality of the CPU cooler you install, and the efficiency of airflow in your computer case.

    55*C is not too hot for an Intel Northwood during gaming. For overclocking though, you'd want better cooling than that.

    Northbridge cooler noise. Yes, I hear you. One of the standard motherboard modifications for me has become removing stock, active NB coolers, replacing them with oversized passive heatsinks. It's cheap, effective, and the buzzzzzwhine is gone!
  • edited May 2004
    Leo's feeding your some prime info here, Bond007uk. He brings up a very good point about the power supply as the 9800XT needs a lot of power; probably a lot more than the board you are replacing. What size and brand psu do you have in your machine?

    That Asus board you are talking about is an i865 chipset board, I believe, and should perform well. The 2 Abit boards you mention are both excellent performers; I have both the IS7 and an IC7-G and they are everything that Leo states. The IS7 is in a dedicated folding machine with just 1 stick of ram, so I can't directly compare it's performance to my IC7-G, but it should be damn close. I imagine that the Asus board should perform similarly to the IS7 but that's just taking a guess as I don't know anyone using that board.
  • edited May 2004
    It's not a power problem as i have tried 3 PSU's with this machine one was 350W and the other two were 400W and still no joy!

    I ran the card in a friends pc, althought he has a different motherboard his machine has running the same amount of stuff that mine has e.g one HDD two cd roms etc. This other machine also had the same power supply as mine, yet when i ran this card on this system it performed beautifuly getting a about 6200 3d marks in 3dmark 2003!
  • edited May 2004
    Are the chipset fans on the Abit boards realy loud or just iritating? I already have a quiet CPU fan (only runs at 2200 in windows, and 2500 in games)

    Just wondered about the extra noise as although i am confident about fitting the motherboard (i have built about 4 pc's) i am not confident about removing the fan on the northbridge and replacing with a passive cooler if it is deemed to loud or buzzy.
  • edited May 2004
    I don't find that the nb fans on my Abit boards loud at all, but I have quite a few fans in the case anyways. :) However, if you do want to change it out, the 2 Abit boards make it real easy because the nb heatsinks are held on by a hook and loop system, not by push pins through the board. The nb itself looks like an old P3 coppermine proc; it's a flip chip design with no heat spreader on top of it.
Sign In or Register to comment.