Two Great Disk Management Applications!

ThraxThrax 🐌Austin, TX Icrontian
edited May 2006 in Science & Tech
One area of my computer that usually goes ignored is the state of my hard drives; my drives are characteristically exhibit fragmentation 80% or above because I'm simply very lazy when it comes to taking care of menial tasks like this on my PC.

Lately I was presented with the task of merging five partitions on a single 120GB disk together; I'm a stickler for organisation, and these partitions have ably served the size demands I've placed on them for 3+ years. Lately, however, my game drive has been running out of room, and with the LAN looming on the horizon, that's one thing I didn't want to face, so it was time to merge them.

Partition Magic 8 had been my old standby for any partition merging/splitting requirements, but on this task, no matter how many times I defragged (back to that in a moment) or ran chkdsk, it said it couldn't complete the task. POPPYCOCK!

Shorty has been extolling the virtues of the Acronis company for some time now, and I found they have an application called Disk Director that performs the same functions as Partition Magic. I thought I'd give it a shot, but before I did that, I wanted to make sure my partitions were in proper order and properly defragmented.

We all know the Windows defragmenter sucks.. Even after it's done, it leaves little red lines of fragmentation everywhere, and that really cheesed me off. I dashed off to Google to find a better defragmenting app, not having been pleased with Diskkeeper. I ran across a program called PerfectDisk by a company called Raxco. After doing the first partition with this program, I knew it was a keeper. Everything was lined up so neatly and beautifully, it blew the native defragger for XP out of the water. So I defragged all my disks with it, rebooted, and got prepared to merge.

Acronis' interfaces with chkdsk, and I ran that on all my defragged partitions before I started the process. A couple drives had tiny errors that Acronis corrected, and I was ready to start merging! I have to say that the process was very quick and trouble-free. No scary errors, no glitches, no hiccups.. Just ~15 minutes per merge procedure, and it was done.

I have to say I'm really impressed with both these programs. Just thought I'd toss those out there. :)

Your friendly local Raxco and Acronis Vice-Shill,
Thraxy-poo

Comments

  • edited May 2006
    Just out of curiosity, whats your problem with Diskkeeper?
  • ThraxThrax 🐌 Austin, TX Icrontian
    edited May 2006
    Its defrags weren't as thorough as they could be. Better than the native XP defragger, but they were still fairly sloppy.
  • EssoEsso Stockholm, Sweden
    edited May 2006
    I have fond out that sometimes I need to run the Perfectdisk 7.0, up to 3 times before it's done.
    But it runs fast.

    Also I keep the Win XP partitions at ~ 20 GB in size, so I don't have to waste time defragging one huge OS partition.
    The defragger needs to have some free space on the partition in order to work fast, it moves out files during the operation.
  • primesuspectprimesuspect Beepin n' Boopin Detroit, MI Icrontian
    edited May 2006
    I had a very, very sad experience with PerfectDisk (read: data was lost), and thus vowed never to use it again.

    Diskeeper, I have been using since v6, and it rocks. I personally think v9 is the best, 10 is a little bit weird on the user interface, but I think diskeeper is the best defrag out there. I recommend it to all my clients.

    Not thorough? Can you describe?
  • RWBRWB Icrontian
    edited May 2006
    I love DK9 as well, been using 10 and it ain't too bad seems more like a UI upgrade to me. What Iam curious about is why the damned thing doesn't put my page file at the front of the disk, it just seems to leave it alone all the time.
  • ThraxThrax 🐌 Austin, TX Icrontian
    edited May 2006
    Not thorough: Even after running DK9 numerous times on two hard drives with more than enough space for temporary shuffling mid-defrag, there was still heavy fragmentation on the drives.
  • KyleKyle Lafayette, LA New
    edited May 2006
    I experienced the same problem as Thrax with Diskkeeper (don't remember if it was version 9 or 10).

    Both of my drives were moderately fragmented with plenty of space to defrag. When Diskkeeper tried to defrag, it "finished" almost instantly without doing anything. A reboot and a reinstall didn't fix it so I gave up when the Windows defrag worked fine.
  • KwitkoKwitko Sheriff of Banning (Retired) By the thing near the stuff Icrontian
    edited May 2006
    I've also experienced data corruption with Perfectdisk. Never had any problems with DK, and I'm going to petition my boss to get the enterprise release for the office.
Sign In or Register to comment.