If geeks love it, we’re on it

Introducing Vanilla Reactions on Icrontic

Introducing Vanilla Reactions on Icrontic

Icrontic launches Vanilla Reactions

We’ve rolled out several new community-building features recently. Everything we’ve implemented has been a direct result of the transition to Vanilla Forums and the resultant ability to implement cool new features relatively easily.

Icrontic "I Exist" BadgeA few months ago we rolled out Icrontic Badges. Badges are a way to show off your “Icronticness” in your user profile. The more you participate in the community, the more rewarding it is for you and for the rest of the community. Badges are a great way to give community members a “roadmap” of how to best participate in this community. If there’s a badge for something, chances are you’re going to find it a rewarding experience to earn it. Playing a game with other Icrontians, meeting new people, sharing your favorite band, having a beer with old friends… what’s not to love? You can see a full list of all the badges to plot your ascension to Icrontic fame.

After badges, we implemented the “Community Scoreboard”. It’s a fun way to see how you stack up against your fellow Icrontians on a month-to-month basis. When we put the scoreboard in, people started scrambling to earn badges so they could one-up their friends. “I can’t possibly let Cannonfodder be higher than me on the scoreboard. SCOREBOARD.”

Next, we began revamping the badge artwork to match our brand. We color coded them orange for gaming, silver for event participation, blue for technical achievements, purple for hobbies, and gold for community contributions. We’re not done yet (there are a lot of badges to cover), but they look far better on a user profile and the bright and recognizable artwork encourages people to get involved. After all, the shiny is important!

Finally, for months and months, people have been asking time and time again for a way to “Like” or “+1” posts. I’m proud to announce that today is your day, friends.

Today we’ve turned on Reactions. Reactions give you the ability to reward community members who contribute positive content with an “Awesome” or a “LOL” on their post. Each upvote adds a point to the user’s score total. Karma or Rep systems have always been an important factor in online forums—if a member has a massive amount of positive reputation, you can generally expect that the words coming out of their keyboard are, at the very least, trustworthy.

You access reactions in the bottom-right corner of any post:

Accessing Icrontic Reactions

You can “awesome” a post if you feel that it deserves it. If a post makes you literally laugh out loud or spit coffee on your screen, give ’em a “LOL”. If the post is a major derailment, click that ol’ Off Topic button.

We hope that you enjoy the new Reactions system. Get badges, make great posts, and thrash your friends on the scoreboard!

Comments

  1. bright
    bright I don't see myself using the reactions at all. I'll probably forget they're there.
  2. Thrax
    Thrax Oh god, finally. Yessssss.
  3. CB
    CB Questions. I have them: How much feedback is there built in to the system? We can see which posts of ours have been plussed? Who plussed them? Will others be able to see the same info? Will the 'reliability' numbers be added to postbits?
  4. Thrax
    Thrax It's all in your profile, CB.
  5. Linc
    Linc @CB I'm not planning on adding specific numeric data to profiles, but I am planning on using the information to guide people to better answers.
  6. BuddyJ
    BuddyJ Great success!
  7. Kwitko
    Kwitko This is very cool, although it could be misused.
    I have a feeling a certain someone's posts will be Off-Topiced to death.
    Maybe.
  8. Linc
    Linc There are also new automatic badges for the 'Awesome' and 'LOL' reactions (at 5, 25, 100, 250, and 500 each).
  9. midga
    midga You should add automatic badges for 'off topic' too. :3
  10. Snarkasm
    Snarkasm What about something like kudos for things that are actually helpful? Awesome can technically encompass that, but it just kind of emphasizes just how broad Awesome is.
  11. Theironhand
    Theironhand With the addition of the Reactions, I've found that I can no longer quote other peoples post, it use to show up on the right top corner.
  12. Linc
    Linc That's been fixed just now. It's now inline with the Reactions.

    We also shrank the size of the Reactions in the last update, which I just applied now.
  13. Linc
    Linc Comments with +5 positive reactions or more get highlighted now.

    I see it's not looking so hot on the dark theme, which I'll fix soon.
  14. CB
    CB Whoop, I think I had to refresh the CSS or somehting, now it's showing much more detailed feedback in the post. :)
  15. UPSLynx
    UPSLynx This is awesome. I love this SO MUCH.

    gibbe upboats plz
  16. primesuspect
    primesuspect
    This is awesome. I love this SO MUCH.

    gibbe upboats plz
    If THQ would like some consulting, please have your boss contact ShortMedia #BMS

  17. UPSHitman
    UPSHitman Wow these forums just keep getting better and better! Nice work Fellas!
  18. fatcat
    fatcat woohoo up-voting go!

    yea I'm looking at you @Thrax @pragtastic @tiberiuslazarus

    image
  19. Thrax
    Thrax Why are you looking at me?! I discovered it!
  20. primesuspect
    primesuspect They'll get their 50 points and then get bored of it.
  21. pragtastic
    pragtastic What can I say, farmers gonna farm.

    Edit: points-points-points-points-points
  22. TiberiusLazarus
  23. GHoosdum
    GHoosdum Since you mentioned this as being something of a 'karma' system in the article, is there a negative repercussion to being labeled off topic? I hope not, since this is Icrontic, after all.

    Also, before I read the "Promote" subtext I thought that graphic was showing the Icrontic salute.
  24. TiberiusLazarus
    TiberiusLazarus 'Awesome' and 'LOL' are apparently +1 to your user score (the score that determines your place on the scoreboard).

    'Off topic' is -1 to the same. :/
  25. GHoosdum
    GHoosdum It also appears that five 'off topic' votes buries the post. I really think that particular set of functionality takes away something that is truly Icrontian - the fact that we can take posts waaaaaaay off topic but still manage to add value and maintain a sense of camaraderie.
  26. TiberiusLazarus
    TiberiusLazarus Ya...

    So far this system is making me want to post less than I already do.
  27. shwaip
    shwaip
    Ya...

    So far this system is making me want to post less than I already do.
    so you're saying the feature is working as intended?
  28. fatcat
    fatcat this is what happens when you give kids guns...

    anyone wanna join me in "off-topic'n" the hell out of @primesuspect score? ;)
  29. Linc
    Linc We've disabled the off-topic reaction. We discussed it and agreed down-voting is bullshit.
  30. Snarkasm
    Snarkasm Any thoughts on the "helpful" or similar one? Perhaps worth 3 points?
  31. Linc
    Linc The only thing close is "Insightful" which I guess I could hack to say "Helpful". Brian and I are actually talking about whether to drop the "LOL" reaction and make it 1 simple up-vote reaction.
  32. Thrax
    Thrax I kinda like the LOLs. It's different from "awesome," I think.
  33. GnomeQueen
    GnomeQueen I do agree that LOL is different from awesome, but I guess I don't like LOL itself...? I don't know, reminds me of 11 year olds.

    How about Trolololol? haha.

    (Don't mind me, I just need more cheese with my whine)
  34. Linc
    Linc How 'bout "Awesomesauce" and "Lulz"? :D
  35. GnomeQueen
    GnomeQueen Hahaha I like "Lulz" :D
  36. shwaip
    shwaip I suggest going the other way. Rather than "awesomesauce" and "lulz", can we have "meh" and "heh"?
  37. midga
    midga Could we have a downvote called "Tim" that only shows up on Tim's posts?
  38. RyanFodder
    RyanFodder But then we'd be feeding the trolls.
  39. QuadyTheTurnip
    QuadyTheTurnip Time to put on my curmudgeon hat.

    I'll be happy to be proven wrong, but in general I'm not a fan of +1 and -1 systems in forums. Having them appear on the posts themselves is fine, but far too often I've seen systems where there are accumulated points lead to some people trying to either game the system or create posts specifically to gain points, thus lowering the quality of discourse. You'll probably end up thinking of Reddit when you read this, but there are other communities I've participated in that had similar systems and similar headaches.

    I hope you at least have systems in place to deal with vote spamming. And in order to both test this and offset my curmudgeon-y response, I have Awesomesauce'D everyone in this thread. EVERYONE. Because, you're all awesome.

    Ok, curmudgeon hat off.
  40. Linc
    Linc There's no -1 system. It's only positive.

    I don't see the problem with clicking 'Awesome' on every comment or why I'd want to code a system to stop you.
  41. RyanFodder
    RyanFodder I now feel slightly less awesome about my comment, seeing as everyone got one :P
  42. Ilriyas
    Ilriyas I totally wasn't paranoid enough of everything already.

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!