If geeks love it, we’re on it

Thermalright T-Rad² review

Thermalright T-Rad² review

Testing

A Sapphire Radeon HD 3870 512MB GDDR4 (770mhz core/ 1125mhz RAM) with Catalyst 8.10 drivers was used for testing on a Gigabyte GA-MA78GM-S2H mATX motherboard with an AMD Phenom X3 8750 processor and the stock AMD heatsink in a Thermaltake Lanbox Lite mATX case with an OCZ 720W EvoStream power supply. The card was tested at idle and then full load using Folding@Home’s GPU client to achieve 100 percent GPU load over a 10 min period in a 26°C room with the case lid off.

Testing was done with dual Xigmatek XSF-F9251 92mm fans. We contacted the engineers at Thermalright and it was their recommendation to test with dual 37 cfm fans.

Use double 92*92*25mm fans on the T-rad2. 2000RPM . noise level 24dbA. 37CFM.
For the ATI 4850 & 4870 vga card test. 92mm fan*2 it’s our recommend
For 9800+ , 9800GTX 9600GT (G94 core) single 12cm fan it’s cool enough.

The Xigmateks push 37.8cfm at 28dB and fit the bill nicely. We did not test with the 120mm fan as a single 120mm fan blowing the same cfm, while quieter, does not offer the same performance potential because it can not cover the entire surface area of the T-Rad². Users opting for a 120mm fan should only do so when looking for quiet computer cooling and not maximum performance.

Conclusion

The T-Rad² performs admirably, especially so when considering that it maintains the same sound levels at idle and load. The stock ATI cooler on the HD 3870 has a high-pitched whine similar to a muffled hairdryer and reminiscent of the old Delta 60mm “screamer” fans popular with hardcore (and possibly deaf) enthusiasts just a few years ago. When the GPU is stressed, the card becomes a noisy annoyance. Conversely, the T-Rad²’s sonic footprint isn’t any greater than an enthusiast PSU.

Other GPU coolers on the market may out-perform the T-Rad² in some cases, but they often require users to sacrifice space and extra motherboard slots or SLI/Crossfire compatibility for and extra degree or two of cooling performance. The only real downside to the T-Rad² is its price. The $59.95 suggested retail price is very steep for an aftermarket cooler; especially when that cooler does not come with any fans. The inclusion of a high-quality TIM can account for some of the high price, and the build quality of the T-Rad² is amazing, but the price premium makes the T-Rad² less attractive to users who do not need the slim profile.

In the end, the cooler’s well-executed design, swank looks, and admirable performance win out for this reviewer. The T-Rad² combines form and function into a compact, well-rounded package. As a new product, its availability on retail shelves is a bit slim at the moment but we expect to see it available through most major online vendors soon.

Pros:
Good performance
Compact fit
Ease of installation
Robust package

Cons:
May interfere with motherboard components
Price

« Previous

Comments

  1. Komete
    Komete Wow that thing looks monstrous. Looks like video card heatsinks are catching up with cpu heatsink in size and design categories. Great review.
  2. BuddyJ
    BuddyJ Thanks Komete. It's pretty large, but when compared to what else is out there on the market, it's a small fry.
  3. Komete
    Komete I guess it's been about two years since I last looked at VGA coolers. I once had a zalman v something. Taking a look on newegg, they are bigger. But that one looks like it is running with the pack. I'm thinking, sooner or later they'll have to redesign cases and cooling paths to accommodate the need for future gpu coolers.
  4. BuddyJ
    BuddyJ Yep, from what I gather, this one runs well above average, but if you want the best in VGA air cooling, there are others that'll net you a few more degrees. The other Thermalright model is one of them, and the Arctic Cooling Accelero Twin Turbo supposedly is equal to or better than the TRad2. I'd love to review both of them and compare results to the TRad2.
  5. Leonardo
    Leonardo
    the Arctic Cooling Accelero Twin Turbo
    I don't know about the "Twin Turbo" part, but I run two of the Accelero coolers on 8800GTs. They are superb. Although you can easily run video cards with the Accelero with no fan at all, I've mounted low-flow (quiet) 120mm fans on mine. Overkill? Definitely! :bigggrin:

    With these big coolers, I assume the T-rad thing also, you can run video cards dead silent at full load.

    Nice work on the review, Buddy J!
  6. BuddyJ
    BuddyJ The engineers at Thermalright don't recommend running the TRad2 without a fan for whatever reason. I took their word for it instead of risking roasting my only good video card. ;)

    The Accelero Twin Turbo is pretty much what you've got, but they've gone and mounted dual 80mm thin fans to it. The guys over at Legion Hardware have reviewed both coolers if you're interested.
  7. Leonardo
    Leonardo OK, I know what you're talking about now. I already had quiet, low-flow 120mm fans in my parts bin, so I just mounted them. Think back to just a few years ago. Who would have thought of a VGA cooler that would easily accept a 1 2 0 millimeter fan! LOL

    I have two machines running 8800GTs, overclocked and at full load. Both those video cards are cooled with Acceleros mounted with 120s. Ambient room temperature now is 74F (heat in the house radiates up to the top floor). One card is running at 41C and the other at 44C.

    I think the TRad2's design and execution is very good, but at 50-80% higher cost than the Accelero, I just don't see it.

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!