If geeks love it, we’re on it

PC2-8500 Memory Roundup

PC2-8500 Memory Roundup

Crucial Ballistix PC2-8500

Crucial is a wholly owned subsidiary of Micron Technology. Micron is one of the world’s leading providers of advanced semiconductor solutions, including DRAM and Flash memory modules. Crucial has been sporting the Ballistix brand for a few years now and they are back with a fresh new look for their DDR2 modules. There are two flavors available for the enthusiast crowd currently: Ballistix and Ballistix Tracers. They function identically, but the ‘Tracers’ provide LED lighting to appeal to those looking for something to show off in a windowed case. The kit I’ll be taking a look at today is the Crucial Ballistix PC2-8500 kit.

Specifications (taken from Ballistix product page)

  • Part Number: BL2KIT12864AA1065
  • Capacity: 2GB kit (1GBx2)
  • Type: DDR2 240-pin DIMM, Unbuffered, NON-ECC
  • Rated Frequency: DDR2 PC2-8500 (1066MHz)
  • Rated Timings: 5-5-5-15
  • Rated vDIMM: 2.2V
  • Approximate Retail Price: $89.00USD (with MIRs that can take it as low as $64.99USD)

Crucial uses a unique and very functional packaging for their Ballistix memory modules. A cardboard box with cardboard spacers keep the modules safe during transport. Each module is individually packaged in an anti-static bag.

The Ballistix are very good looking DIMMs. The newer heatspreaders were originally introducted with their ‘Anniversary Edition’ memory and are now used on all Ballistix DIMMs.

The PCB is black beneath the yellow-gold heat spreaders which creates a nice contrast and a high quality appearance. I don’t know why most manufacturers use green. Ask any enthusiast, and they’ll tell you that black PCB looks best in most situations. Green seems to clash with just about everything. Crucial clearly listened.

The adhesive thermal pad failed to make proper contact with the ICs on both DIMMs. Squeezing it together by hand did temporarily correct the problem but it came apart again, unfortunately. The ICs on the side of the DIMM in question are not going to be transferring heat very well. After a quick browse around some forums, a few others had this issue and corrected it by allowing the modules to heat up quite a bit before trying to squeeze them together again. I’m hoping this is just an isolated issue with a batch of DIMMs.

I had no issues getting these modules to boot. Setting vDIMM and the correct frequency in the BIOS was all that was required. Crucial has programmed several SPD profiles, including two enhanced performance profiles for PC2-6400 and PC2-8500 frequencies.

Overclocking and Frequency Scaling

We put the Ballistix kit through its paces on our Intel test rig outlined in the ‘Testing Methodology’ section.

WARNING: Increasing memory voltage beyond manufacturer specifications can be harmful to the modules and other system components. Although we subject modules to high levels of vDIMM for testing purposes, many of these results are not suitable for 24/7 use. Always consult with your memory manufacturer to see what a maximum ‘safe’ voltage is for 24/7 use. Increase memory voltage at your own risk!

The modules just kept climbing until they reached a very impressive 1300MHz. I was very pleased to see 1200MHz, but 1300MHz is truly exceptional. It is a pretty steep vDIMM curve to acheive the last 100MHz at 5-5-5 timings.

Things looked just as positive with 4-4-4 timings. The Ballistix kit topped out just shy of 1200MHz. Most kits can not hit 1180MHz with 5-5-5 timings, let alone 4-4-4 timings. Very good!

The Ballistix were able to clock an impressive 900MHz at super tight 3-3-3 timings. Very impressive as well. This kit responded very well to vDIMM at tighter timings, which is typical of Micron D9 based modules.

« Previous Next page »

Comments

  1. BuddyJ
    BuddyJ Another win! Excellent review Mike!
  2. Winfrey
    Winfrey heh, "golden fedora"! Icrontic has the best rating system ever ;D

    Great job Mike! Excellent read!
  3. Zuntar
    Zuntar Nicely done mike, as usual!!!:respect::rockon:
  4. Qeldroma
    Qeldroma A lot of what I want in a memory review with memory I look at when I shop. I'm even looking at about the same flavor of mobo ... and a quadly to boot! This is a decent test case for me and probably the enthuiast mainstream. I'm eyeing power as well as performance- so that's definitely a bene.

    I was kind of surprised at the Crucials and wondered if there might be a correlation to the power draw ... or even the poor thermal contact. Regardless, they look like great sticks.

    Looked like a fun bunch to play with. gj
  5. TheLostSwede
    TheLostSwede Excellent review Mike. I like your style. A lot.
  6. lemonlime
    lemonlime Thanks for the comments, all! Had a great time putting it together :)
  7. mmonnin
    mmonnin Mike, my Ballistix also has the same problem with 1 side of the heatspreader not making full contact.
  8. mas0n
    mas0n I have 2 of these same Ballistix kits and the spreaders make full contact on both sides.

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!