If geeks love it, we’re on it

This is a man’s world: Women and smartphone keyboards

This is a man’s world: Women and smartphone keyboards

I have small hands. They’re not super small—my younger sister sports much tinier digits–but they’re definitely not close to the size of an average man’s. For that reason, my Droid drives me crazy. In fact, so does every high-end smartphone. They just weren’t made for hands like mine.

Why I went smart

I wanted a high-end smartphone that utilized Android. After looking at several different phones, including the G1 and the Nexus One, I chose the Droid because it handles the tasks that I need to accomplish much faster than the older G1, and it has a physical keyboard, which the Nexus One lacks.

I was also excited to say goodbye to my tiny old Samsung, which was not only slow, but lacked a QWERTY keyboard. Typing on it was time consuming and annoying, and browsing the web was almost entirely out of the question.

I have had my Droid for about four months now, but I find myself missing the keyboard on my shitty Samsung. Don’t get me wrong—it’s nice not having to hit the “7” key four times to get the letter “S”–but it’s far more difficult for me to navigate the Droid’s keyboard than I expected.

The keyboard conundrum

I was severely let down to realize that what I wanted most, a smoother and faster typing experience, was not what I would be getting with the Droid. The phone was obviously created for someone with bigger hands than me–someone male.

Though I do ultimately enjoy the Droid, I am frustrated by the lack of devices suited to users like me: women that want high-end smartphones with smaller keyboards. In fact, today’s premiere handsets–the iPhone 3GS, Droid, Nexus One, and HD2–were all obviously made with larger hands in mind. When used with their ideal landscape orientation, these four phones measure 4.55, 4.56, 4.7 and 4.74 inches wide, respectively.

If these devices are any indication, then average size of the flagship smartphone is gradually increasing over time. It makes sense, too: bigger, better screens are fast becoming a hot commodity.

All of this isn’t to say that there are no smartphones with smaller keyboards or portrait orientations, however. The Palm Pre Plus and RIM’s QWERTY BlackBerries boast portrait orientation and a better fit for my hands. The Palm Pixi Plus has been particularly noted for its tiny keyboard, but that’s probably because it was created for women. (My colleagues have noted that the Pixi is the “mommy blogger phone.”)

While these phones might better fit my hand, the BlackBerry’s cruddy OS and Palm’s middling hardware make for lacking designs; they don’t hold a candle to the phones with the experience I really want.

Digging deeper

I’m not saying that the tech industry is dreadfully sexist or has deliberately conspired to keep me down with big phones. In fact, the reason why smartphones are catered towards men is clear: men dominate the tech industry, so it makes sense that its products would fit their needs. Furthermore, according to a study done by Google, 58% of smartphone users are male. Phone manufacturers are simply looking out for what their user base wants and needs, and the majority of that user base are male.

Even so, it’s extremely frustrating that 42% of US smartphone users are ignored by high-end phone makers, especially in this day and age. It seems as though very few gadgets are made with a woman in mind–unless, of course, you describe revamping an existing product with a pink bezel and flowers as “keeping a woman in mind.” If the Droid was pink, I’d totally think it was made just for me, right?! OMG!

Perhaps I’m simply getting my pants in a bunch over a relatively small issue, but I am frustrated by the lack of high-end devices that also offer a tactile experience I find comfortable. And, perhaps one day, a company will release a phone which offers exactly that. For now, I only have one request: make me a phone!

Comments

  1. Ryder
    Ryder Great article Jackie, I like the style.
  2. ardichoke
    ardichoke It probably doesn't help that the Droid's keyboard is just plain shitty. For everyone. Not just small handed women. I have yet to meet a Droid owner that actually likes the keyboard.
  3. Snarkasm
    Snarkasm That's one thing software keyboards do better than hardware ones - you can throw your fingers very quickly around a soft keyboard, and there's great autocorrection to back it up. If you don't press quite hard enough on a physical keyboard, there's no getting around it - you have to go back and hit that bastard again.

    Great article, but as a man with big hands, I'm happy. Hope you get what you're looking for.
  4. Cliff_Forster
    Cliff_Forster How about this new fan-dangled Samsung swipe typing method?
  5. ardichoke
    ardichoke Are you referring to Swype Cliff? AFAIK, that is not affiliated with Samsung. I do want to try it out though...
  6. Cliff_Forster
    Cliff_Forster Yeah, thats it. I know Samsung has a phone they have been marketing with it. Seems interesting.
  7. MachineDog
    MachineDog Swype is shit, you can use the beta on any android phone. It would work if you used a stylus, but using your thumbs it is hard to see where your fingers are going on the keyboard.


    HTC is supposed to be releasing a portrait-oriented Android phone later this year that should fit better.
  8. Snarkasm
    Snarkasm How do you make a portrait-oriented phone? If you turn it 90 degrees, it's a landscape phone again.
  9. MachineDog
    MachineDog Blackberry-style.
  10. BobbyDigi
    BobbyDigi I'm sorry I missed the problem. I understand small hands, but what problem does this cause? Thumbs can not reach the center?

    -Bobby
  11. Bandrik
    Bandrik I have relatively small hands, myself... but I've considered that a benefit, that I have finer control on small keyboards that mobile devices have over people with larger hands. Hell, in reviews I often will read things like "keyboard/buttons/whatever were a little hard to use, but then again I have fat hands, sausage-fingers, etc".

    Off-topic, I really liked the idea of the Swype input method. I don't know if it'll actually catch on, but thinking outside the box like that is really neat.

    Now if only we had that Minority Report tech on a phone. :D
  12. fatcat
    fatcat ah, shoulda got a G1
  13. ardichoke
    ardichoke I can sell you mine if you want :D

    The G1 has a great hardware keyboard IMHO, but it's memory and processor are disappointing.
  14. fatcat
    fatcat yup, absolutely love the G1 keyboard. hopefully they make a G2 someday with all that fancy new hardware and the same awesome keyboard
  15. ardichoke
    ardichoke You mean like the upcoming T-Mobile MyTouch Slide? The keyboard isn't exactly the same but looks quite similar, plus it's supposed to be rocking an ARM11 processor.
  16. Shorty
    Shorty Jackie,

    I am the same. I was so pleased to hear that Apple had created a portrait keyboard into the jesus phone OS. Shame that when I got to use it, I realised my dinky hands couldn't actually use it comfortably :(

    For those who don't quite understand the issue. Take your landscape phone and move your hands a few CMs further left & right. Then try to type the middle keys... not so easy is it?
  17. Thrax
    Thrax
    ardichoke wrote:
    You mean like the upcoming T-Mobile MyTouch Slide? The keyboard isn't exactly the same but looks quite similar, plus it's supposed to be rocking an ARM11 processor.

    The ARM11 chip in the myTouch slide is supposed to be the Qualcomm MSM720x chip, which was used in the HTC Dream, Magic and Hero. In other words, it's a glorified G1, and not at all a high-end smartphone.
  18. FLUFFY! :D Are those pink balloons?
  19. petesmom
    petesmom I bought, yup, you guessed it, a pink phone w/a small qwerty keyboard. Only problem - it was crap. Droid feels like carrying a shoebox in my small hands. Now using an old iPhone. Why? Cuz it was available. How hard can it be to make a comfortable, easy to use phone for 48% of the population? Good topic, GQueen!
  20. ardichoke
    ardichoke
    Thrax wrote:
    The ARM11 chip in the myTouch slide is supposed to be the Qualcomm MSM720x chip, which was used in the HTC Dream, Magic and Hero. In other words, it's a glorified G1, and not at all a high-end smartphone.

    I dunno, according to what I just read the specs have leaked. 600HMz processor, 512MB RAM and 512MB storage. Those aren't super high end but it's not what I would call bad by any means. Also seems to be coming with Swype keyboard pre-loaded. If they price it aggressively it could be a very nice phone for people that want a reasonably priced smartphone with a good hardware keyboard.
  21. Soso I've got an HTC Legend (only released on Europe as far as I know) with a swype keybord for weeks now. To put it simply: it's quite wonderfull

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!