Geforce 4 MX 440SE or Geforce 2 GTS?

SleepstalkerSleepstalker
edited June 2003 in Hardware
I have an older pc with a Hercules Geforce 2 GTS. I would like to upgrade the graphics card a bit but don't won't too spend much since it's my secondary pc. Will I notice a big difference if I get the Albatron Geforce 4 MX 440SE. I noticed it's only $50 at Newegg. The memory clock is only listed as 200, I can't remember my gf2 clock speeds off the top of my head but I'm pretty sure the memory clock is higher than 200. Can anyone tell me if the GF4MX will actually be noticeably faster? Think it might be able to run UT2003 at medium setting so I can get some network games going?
«1

Comments

  • DoM-aLDoM-aL Indiana
    edited June 2003
    I'd stick with the geforce 2 or else buy a cheap gf4ti4200.
  • karatekidkaratekid Ogdensburg, NY
    edited June 2003
    As much as I hate Tom's Hardware, you gotta love their charts of 30+ video cards. http://www17.tomshardware.com/graphic/20030120/vgacharts-02.html

    Despite being called a Geforce 4, the MX line is based on Geforce 2 technology, with slighly more preformace (about 5% in most of the charts in the link.) I would say it is a waste of 50 bucks.
  • MattMatt
    edited June 2003
    stay with the geforce2 gts.
  • Omega65Omega65 Philadelphia, Pa
    edited June 2003
    Originally posted by matt
    stay with the geforce2 gts.
    Ditto - they both have the same level of peformance.

    Avoid all GFx-MX type cards. Nvidia makes them for suckers.

    Either keep your money or get a DX8 (GF3 or GF4 or Radeon 8500/9100) or aDX9 (ATI Radeon 9500/9600 or GF-FX 5600 or higher card) capable card.
  • SleepstalkerSleepstalker
    edited June 2003
    What's the deal with the Geforce FX 5200? I see one with a couple good reviews at Newegg for only $75. It's the VGA CHAINTECH Geforce FX 5200 128MB DDR. 8x AGP ,128 megs DDR, and for the most part DX9 compatible. Is this a good upgrade from the geforce 2 or is it just the mx of the fx series?
  • DoM-aLDoM-aL Indiana
    edited June 2003
    http://www.icrontic.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=372
  • SleepstalkerSleepstalker
    edited June 2003
    Ok so no sub $100 graphics card upgrade for me. No smooth running UT2k3 network play for my friends. I'll just move my 4600 over to my old comp when I upgrade in half a year or so.
    Thanks for the help guys.

    Edit: I made this thread by accident it was supposed to be a new reply to my other thread, and now I can't delete it. Sorry for the confusion.
  • SleepstalkerSleepstalker
    edited June 2003
    Ok so no sub $100 graphics card upgrade for me. No smooth running UT2k3 network play for my friends. I'll just move my 4600 over to my old comp when I upgrade in half a year or so.
    Thanks for the help guys.
  • ClutchClutch North Carolina New
    edited June 2003
    That sucks man. Maybe you can gather up some money to get your upgrade on the way, if not just means you get a even better upgrade in the future.
  • drowddrowd Texas
    edited June 2003
    yeah, just wait till some of the newer cards come out, and move the 4600 in your current computer down to the back up and toss the new card in to your current computer . . .
  • MattMatt
    edited June 2003
    How much is the ti4600 now?
  • EMNEMN
    edited June 2003
    Originally posted by Sleepstalker
    Ok so no sub $100 graphics card upgrade for me. No smooth running UT2k3 network play for my friends. I'll just move my 4600 over to my old comp when I upgrade in half a year or so.
    Thanks for the help guys.

    Edit: I made this thread by accident it was supposed to be a new reply to my other thread, and now I can't delete it. Sorry for the confusion.

    Fixed. ;)
  • MattMatt
    edited June 2003
    Originally posted by Sleepstalker
    Ok so no sub $100 graphics card upgrade for me. No smooth running UT2k3 network play for my friends. I'll just move my 4600 over to my old comp when I upgrade in half a year or so.
    Thanks for the help guys.

    you have a ti4600 and you cant play ut2003
  • CCWCCW Suffolk, UK
    edited June 2003
    Originally posted by matt
    How much is the ti4600 now?

    NJot mnay places do em anymore, id get a 9500 pro for a budget card, they have DirectX 9.0 support and are very powerful cards

    Craig
  • EnverexEnverex Worcester, UK Icrontian
    edited June 2003
    You can have one from over here, our country is full of crap, please, take the A type TBreds, theres no room for the B Types :(

    NS
  • MattMatt
    edited June 2003
    Originally posted by CCW


    NJot mnay places do em anymore, id get a 9500 pro for a budget card, they have DirectX 9.0 support and are very powerful cards

    Craig
    see my sig i have a 9500pro i dont need a video card but i just want to know how much they are.
  • Geeky1Geeky1 University of the Pacific (Stockton, CA, USA)
    edited June 2003
    go on ebay and get a Radeon 8500... my 64MB BBATi is good for 320 core/295 memory, and it scores 11,000+ in 3dmark2001se...
  • MattMatt
    edited June 2003
    Originally posted by Geeky1
    go on ebay and get a Radeon 8500... my 64MB BBATi is good for 320 core/295 memory, and it scores 11,000+ in 3dmark2001se...
    iv got a 9500pro hacked in to a 9700pro i get over 16000 in 3dmark2001se
  • SleepstalkerSleepstalker
    edited June 2003
    Posted by Matt "you have a ti4600 and you cant play ut2003?"

    The Ti4600 is in my main system. I was just wondering if I could get a cheap (below $100) card to replace the Geforce 2 GTS in my old system. Doesn't look like anything in that pricerange would do enough of a difference to make it worthwhile though.
  • MattMatt
    edited June 2003
    ya that geforce2 gts is good for now you should look in to overclocking to save some money. if you overclock you could get like another 10-50 FPS in ut2003
  • TheSourceTheSource
    edited June 2003
    i got a Geforce4 MX 440 and it runs UT2K3 just fine
  • MattMatt
    edited June 2003
    if you get the MX440 with 8x agp you can run it at 400/800 with no voltage mods. iv had the mx440 with 8x agp and i can say that most of them are running at 370/750 with no mods.
  • Geeky1Geeky1 University of the Pacific (Stockton, CA, USA)
    edited June 2003
    but he was looking for sub-$100 cards I thought... the 9500 is more than $100... at any rate, newegg has refurbed 128mb non-le 8500s for $90... I may buy one...
  • MattMatt
    edited June 2003
    Originally posted by Geeky1
    but he was looking for sub-$100 cards I thought... the 9500 is more than $100... at any rate, newegg has refurbed 128mb non-le 8500s for $90... I may buy one...
    were talking about the geforce4 mx440
  • Geeky1Geeky1 University of the Pacific (Stockton, CA, USA)
    edited June 2003
    actually the initial question was about the mx440, then sleepstalker asked about the fx5200... for less than $100, the only decent cards you'll find are refurbished or used, unless new 128mb ti4200s are less than $100 now... all the FXs are worthless, and the 5200 is the worst of the lot. The GeForce MXs have never exactly been blazingly fast cards either... and ATi doesn't have anything out for less than $100 that's better than the 8500 anyhow... so, his best bet for a graphics card upgrade would be to either wait, as he said, or get a used 8500, or possibly a new 9000/9100... there's nothing else in that price range that's as fast as they are.
  • CCWCCW Suffolk, UK
    edited June 2003
    Originally posted by matt

    see my sig i have a 9500pro i dont need a video card but i just want to know how much they are.

    tried going to www.google.com?

    Craig
  • MattMatt
    edited June 2003
    www.google.com never i just went to www.pricewatch.com and looked.
  • MattMatt
    edited June 2003
    Originally posted by Geeky1
    actually the initial question was about the mx440, then sleepstalker asked about the fx5200... for less than $100,
    i got the FX5200 ultra and i sent it back the next day.

    1) the geforce fx run's way to hot
    2) there was something wronge with my card because at stock speeds i was getting ripping in windows
    3) the fx i had wouldnt overclock to save its life
  • EnisadaEnisada Edmonton Member
    edited June 2003
    Screw getting either of those cards. Just give into your temptation of getting an ATI 9800Pro. You know you want to....
    :D
  • SleepstalkerSleepstalker
    edited June 2003
    I'm not buying another major graphics card until Doom 3 comes out. Once Doom 3 comes out I'll probably buy whatever card runs it best. I sure hope Nvidia wins, I've been using Nvidia ever since 3Dfx died. I have faith that they will make a comeback and reclaim the the crown as graphics king.
Sign In or Register to comment.