If geeks love it, we’re on it

The time is now to send a message: boycott Gamestop

The time is now to send a message: boycott Gamestop

Boycott Gamestop

Disturbing news came from the retail world Wednesday. Ars Technica reports that GameStop stores are physically opening new copies of Deus Ex: Human Revolution on the PC and removing a $50 voucher for OnLive. The voucher would allow consumers to play the game for free using OnLive’s game streaming service.

The voucher is an intelligent play by OnLive to promote their service. With the amount of positive press Human Revolution has gotten, in addition to the massive amounts of hype surrounding the game pre-release, OnLive has massive potential to reach new customers with this promotion. Not surprisingly, GameStop is pressured and threatened by digital distribution, and the decision to remove these vouchers should be recognized as nothing less than anti-competitive.

More shocking than the revelation that these vouchers have been disappearing is the fact that the practice has been completely confirmed as true by GameStop HR representatives. Employees were being instructed to open stock before placing them on shelves.

Thursday morning brought a touch of sensibility—GameStop had responded to massive amounts of criticism by pulling all PC copies of Human Revolution from store shelves. Apparently, stock of the game has been ordered that do not contain the OnLive voucher. In fact, in a memo to all GameStop managers, corporate mentioned specifically that the decision to pull out the vouchers was a direct response to the threat OnLive makes against GameStop’s upcoming streaming service currently in development.

So GameStop have covered their tracks for the time being. Despite their bandage, we need to consider the implications of what this company has done. As consumers, we need to take action.

OnLive is a new service. It offers a new method for consumers to receive content. The service has been met with criticism as well as acclaim, but has yet to gather a considerable user base. The promotion with Deus Ex Human Revolution has great potential to help OnLive reach many new users, and it is a promotion that likely cost OnLive corporate a significant sum of money.

GameStop is the nation’s largest brick-and-mortar video game retailer. Not surprisingly, GameStop is feeling pressure from digital distribution platforms such as Steam and Direct2Drive. OnLive presents a clear challenge to GameStop’s revenue. By GameStop refusing to sell product with the OnLive promotion within, they are not only denying OnLive of many potential users, but they are blocking the company from an unquantifiable amount of income.

GameStop has used their size and power to muscle out the little guy, and they’re going to get away with it. GameStop is modifying product. They are deciding what their customers can and cannot have. They are assuming direct control of the product, and as a retailer, this is not their responsibility. Companies that provide product decide what goes into the box, and they make that decision based on careful research, partnerships, and revenue opportunities. Developers having their product tampered with by the retailer should be absolutely livid at this detestable practice, and you as a consumer should be too.

Imagine Newegg doing what GameStop have done—opening your motherboard package to pull out adapters to promote their own brand. Imagine Steam adding promotions to their own games to the package files before you can download and play the game that you purchased. Such behavior from any major retailer is unimaginable, because what GameStop has done is unprecedented. Nothing good can come from a company making a decision like this and getting away with it.

This is a call to arms. I want you to get mad. I want you to be like Howard Beale in Network when he told his viewers that they need to yell “I’m mad as hell, and I’m not going to take this anymore!” As a gamer and consumer, your rights are being infringed upon if GameStop continues to tamper with the products that you pay money for. Do not tolerate this kind of corporate greed. It’s time to speak with your wallets.

If there was ever a time to boycott a company, that time is now. We should not reward GameStop for this behavior with purchases of any products from under their roofs. As consumers, we have a responsibility to protect our rights. As GameStop laughs in our faces unapologetically, it’s time to show them that we do care about where we buy our games, and we do care about how we are treated as consumers. It’s time to walk away without looking back. There are better alternatives, and better retailers that respect consumers.

Besides, if we don’t take a stand against this corporate giant and let them continue to walk over our rights, our future may be no prettier than that of the world of Deus Ex: Human Evolution.

Comments

  1. fatcat
    fatcat Never bought a game there anyways, boycotting since the internet was born...
  2. Cliff_Forster
    Cliff_Forster I agree 100%. Gamestop just lost me for good.

    Do many of us have those game stop discount cards? Let's stand in unity, get videos cutting them up and send them to corporate. Not kidding, lets make a massive boycott project out of it. I have a card, heck, I have one of the fancy ones you pay $15 for. Lets send them a statement. Power to the players indeed.
  3. GnomeWizardd
    GnomeWizardd Was thinking of going out to game stop to pick up Dragon age II for my mac ( they had it in stock ) but then I saw this yesterday on another site and I said F them! So i bought it from amazon digital download. I am tempted to go pull my Diablo III preorder back
  4. RyanMM
    RyanMM +1 to this. I haven't shopped at Gamestop since they became a glorified pawn shop for used video games.
  5. UPSLynx
    UPSLynx Good man.

    GameStop hasn't seen a dollar from me in years, but this move ensures that they never will get a cent from me again.
  6. drasnor
    drasnor This is news? GameStop opens all the games they sell.
  7. thunder18 I'm not sure why people are suprised gamestop has been doing this for years with videogames. they take new copys of 360 and ps3 games open them store them in a slip cover and put the empty box on the wall but still sell the game as new.
  8. polk tsi400 I don't even know if what they did was legal...I imagine there's going to be a lawsuit if there isn't one already. Once a package was opened i didn't think you could sell as new. This just shows how scared gamestop is right now
  9. NiGHTS
    NiGHTS FWIW, employees are allowed to 'borrow' games for 4 days under a litany of stipulations. Those borrowed copies are sold as new.
  10. UPSLynx
    UPSLynx
    drasnor wrote:
    This is news? GameStop opens all the games they sell.

    Not with PC games, and they certainly haven't been pulling things from the games that they did open.
    I don't even know if what they did was legal...

    It is certainly debatable. Though opening the product and selling as new isn't illegal (it is dirty, though), removing part of the product to block a competitive service in promotion of one's own service IS anti-competitive, which should be grounds for antitrust. I don't know the legal details, but I do know cases of antitrust can be taken to court.
  11. RootWyrm
    RootWyrm GameStop's activities actually do violate O.R.C. §1345.02(B)1, 5 and 9 technically.
    GameStop represented that they had approval from the manufacturer to modify the game from what was delivered; they did not.
    GameStop presented that the game sold there was identical to the offer as stated by the publisher; it was not.
    GameStop presented that they had approval from the manufacturer to remove OnLive codes from the delivered product; they did not.
    They would also be in violation of O.R.C. §1345.03(B)1, 3, 5 and 6 as a result. They removed a $50 value item from a game without disclosing this to customers, they knew the benefit of the removal was entirely one-sided in their favor, they refused to provide or permit returns due to their destruction of the OnLive code, and they stated the game was new as delivered when they knew it was not.

    If a lawyer wanted to make some hay, they could pretty much nail GameStop for $600 for every single copy of DE:HR they sold in Ohio. ($200 or actual damages, whichever is greater, trebled by unconscionable acts clause.) Fortunately, I don't shop at GameStop anyway - the mafia has more ethics.
  12. mertesn
    mertesn
    UPSLynx wrote:
    Not with PC games, and they certainly haven't been pulling things from the games that they did open.
    Actually, they do for PC games as well. My wife picked up a couple new PC games for me a few years ago and the employees had already opened the packages for both games and relocated the keys from the case to the inside of the manuals, nearly destroying one in the process.
  13. UPSLynx
    UPSLynx Hardly surprising anymore, really. It's been so long since i actually shopped there.
  14. CB
    CB I haven't bought a game in a box since the inception of Steam. Boycott accepted. I think you're preaching to the choir here.
  15. Bandrik
    Bandrik Well said, Bobby. I know we've had this very conversation several times in the past. Eff GameStop.

    The last time I really considered their storefront a fun place to shop was back when it was called Electronics Boutique (and not even EB Games yet). Even then, I was highly suspect of their ethics, but at least things were just slightly bruised, rather than just plain rotten to the core.

    Really, my biggest beef with EB/GameStop is their policy of selling opened games as "new", as already mentioned in comments above. This drives me nuts. I refuse to pay a full (if not flat-out overly inflated) retail price for a product that was opened, fingerprinted, and possibly scratched.

    I have a policy: only -I- am allowed to scratch, scuff, and damage a new product. I also enjoy what I call the "shrinkwrap experience": that fresh plastic-y smell you get from opening up the shrinkwrap on a game, movie, or just about anything else. It's a delightful aroma of pure entertainment potential.

    And GameStop continues to rob us of it.

    Seriously. Fuck off, GameStop.


    MaQok.jpg
  16. drasnor
    drasnor Too bad there isn't a real-world Recettear. Capitalism, ho?
  17. kanezfan
    kanezfan I can't remember the last time I bought a game at a store. Who buys a physical product anymore?
  18. primesuspect
    primesuspect Millions of people apparently. There are GameStops everywhere.
  19. Thrax
    Thrax Anyone who played Call of Duty: Black Ops for the 360. Those people.
  20. FreshyP
    FreshyP Aw dude... I bought so many things from that store... This is rough for me.
  21. cola
    cola Yeah, sadly after the way this was handled I'm probably not gonna shop there much anymore.
  22. Jokke
    Jokke Apparently, We have Gamestop in Norway. I'm not all that familiar with the store as I close to never buy video games physically anymore. I don't know if it's even the same Gamestop as over there, but it's likely. They have two sections in their stores, one for used and one for new games. The new games all are wrapped in plastic, if I recall correctly, so they may have a different policy than U.S Gamestops.
  23. Zuntar
    Zuntar GameStop is all but useless for PC games. they are all about PS3, Wii, and XBox360.
  24. GnomeWizardd
    GnomeWizardd Question, where is the best place to pre order online? I pulled my D3 pre order last night
  25. kanezfan
    kanezfan That's true I didn't think about console games. That sucks for consoles. That's pretty crappy that you have to go to a store to buy a game for consoles. Get with the times! How antiquated.
  26. Chris That is incredibly uncouth business ethics. They lost me as a customer a long time ago when they continued charging on average $10 more per game than any other retailer. More than that if you purchase your games digitally, as I now do.

    It's just their final attempt to keep a grip with the tight competition of all the other retailers, both physical and digital. Sad tho that this attempt could have finally driven the nail in the coffin.
  27. UPSLynx
    UPSLynx
    CB wrote:
    I haven't bought a game in a box since the inception of Steam. Boycott accepted. I think you're preaching to the choir here.

    Indubitably, but I wanted to make sure people were aware of the situation. The more I talk about it, the more I'm sickened by GameStop's practices.

    GnomeWizardd, most people who preorder online go with Amazon. They deliver quickly and are totally reliable.
  28. Basil
    Basil Uh oh gamestop, all these people who wouldn't buy from you anyway are gonna boycott ya! :p
  29. Canti
    Canti >tell people to boycott gamestop
    >boycotters already weren't shopping there
    >regular customers don't care
    >nothing changes

    FUCKING GAMESTOP
  30. UPSLynx
    UPSLynx HAHA but it's true D:
  31. Linc
    Linc
    CB wrote:
    I haven't bought a game in a box since the inception of Steam. Boycott accepted. I think you're preaching to the choir here.
    Ding. They still sell games on plastic discs in boxes? That's like reading your news on dead trees.
  32. UPSLynx
    UPSLynx The messages applies to console gamers just as much. No matter what you intend to buy, you shouldn't be doing it at GameStop.
  33. CB
    CB People play games on consoles? My console is for watching Netflix and Hulu.
  34. Thrax
    Thrax People use consoles for an HTPC? My consoles are for anchoring my entertainment center in the event of sudden gravity loss.
  35. Gate28
    Gate28 I still shop at Gamestop and I will continue to. If they and me an opened game I just won't take it and buy it somewhere else, and the people who don't realize that an open game is bad news deserve whatever they get.
  36. AlexDeGruven
    AlexDeGruven They open almost every game they sell, whether it's for PC or console. If it's shrink-wrapped in the store, don't think for a minute that it hasn't been opened. Shrink-wrapping machines are a dime a dozen and any place that does anything even remotely shady (and plenty of legit places, too) will have them in the back.
  37. Fitzkrieg
    Fitzkrieg
    People play games on consoles? My console is for watching Netflix and Hulu.

    When was the last time you were able to play a recent console-exclusive on a PC again?

    Also, I'm a PS3 owner (and damn proud) and I've long since lost my patience with EB Games (GameStop in Canada), I buy my games from an ACTUAL pawn shop.
  38. UPSLynx
    UPSLynx I haven't stepped foot into a Gamestop since I wrote this piece, and it's bullcrap like this that continues to keep my money out of their hands:

    http://www.joystiq.com/2013/01/18/metro-other-thq-games-unavailable-for-impulse-pre-order-due-to/
  39. Chooch
    Chooch I worked for a GameStop for 3 years. One of the worst companies I have ever worked for....
  40. ardichoke
    ardichoke GameStahp is still around?

    News to me.
  41. NiGHTS
    NiGHTS You forgot the on the end of that statement ;)
  42. _k
    _k Didn't they get the state of THQ as a company wrong in that new blurb? I thought they had enough private backing to go through chapter 11 and get a new line of credit to operate.

    Also it seems like if their was any uncertainty from GS on if certain games would be released they would push the pre-order harder because it would be a sale that might not have to be returned when the game never released. Free money for something that was never sold.
  43. midga
    midga Wait, I thought THQ was restructuring, not selling itself (prostiTHQtion, lawl).

    My gameshop of choice is Game Over in Austin. They sell fanart :3
  44. Tushon
    Tushon AFAIK, the original plan for selling all of THQ to one buyer was rejected by a bankruptcy court judge, so they are now going through a longer scenario of selling portions of it off.

    @_k_ I imagine they would be obligated to give your money back or, more GameStop-like, they'd give you in-store credit.
  45. QuadyTheTurnip
    QuadyTheTurnip While Gamestop has issues, I don't think this THQ-preorder situation is one of those. THQs various plans to keep itself together and go into chapter 11 were rejected by their creditors, and more importantly by a bankruptcy court judge, and THQ is now being sold piecemeal (the actual auction of IPs and studios is next week, on the 22nd, IIRC).

    It's a weird jumble of legal shenanigans, but as part of that, it seems perfectly reasonable for Gamestop to halt preorders at the moment of THQ properties. Why? Because with the upcoming piecemeal sale, the various properties THQ owns will be going to wildly different owners, and not all of the games in the works by those companies may end up actually being released. Gamestop is hedging their bets here to keep them from having to deal with a lot of returns and outcry when the games that people preordered don't materialize due to circumstances that Gamestop has no control over. And keep in mind, all released THQ games are still up there, this only affects preorders...

    And frankly, with the sale next week, things will probably get even more shaky for THQ properties when it comes to consumer purchasing. Double Fine, for example, had a number of games that THQ published for them on consoles (though through some interesting events, Double Fine self-published on PC) such as Stacking and Costume Quest, that has led to them throwing their hat into the ring for the THQ auction solely so they can get the full rights to those properties themselves...because if they didn't, those games would most likely have to be removed from places like Xbox Live Marketplace and the PlayStation Store due to the publisher (and thus the entity dealing with the finances of the purchased copies of the games) no longer existing. And it's still entirely possible (though extremely unlikely) that someone else could outbid Double Fine for those properties, in which case they may still have to be removed from those stores until a deal can be made between Double Fine, the new purchaser, and Microsoft/Sony. Don't be surprised if we see similar occurrences in the coming weeks, unfortunately.
  46. Tushon
    Tushon (the silly part about it is that the pre-orders were canceled for PC download, not console discs)
  47. drasnor
    drasnor I can't help but be reminded of this.
  48. Teramona
    Teramona Makes me want to start shopping there so I can stop shopping there.
  49. PirateNinja
    PirateNinja
    (the silly part about it is that the pre-orders were canceled for PC download, not console discs)
    Maybe there is a clause in the distribution contract that holds the publisher liable for console discs, but there is no such clause for the PC downloads. In once case the risk is mitigated and in another it is not. I'm not siding with Gamestop, but I don't think we know the details as to why the decisions were made, plus it is cool to hate Gamestop.

  50. Tushon
    Tushon Sure, just curious is all.
  51. UPSLynx
    UPSLynx Though I cannot comment on THQ's financial situation (obviously), the company is NOT being sold piecemeal. The option is there, yes, but Clearlake's package offer for all of THQ was not outright rejected and still stands. For ANY of our IPs to be sold piecemeal, the aggregate bid of it and/or any other IP specific bids must be greater than the sum Clearlake is offering us plus a significant buffer (i.e. clearlake can't be ebay out-bid by $1 or so, needs to be a significant sum). Until a serious investment shows up to piecemeal THQ, the clearlake bid still stands and THQ still stands to move forward with their capital uninterrupted.

    Those are the facts on the auction, and Gamestop knows that. The fact that they're pulling THQ titles BEFORE the auction date even hits is bullshittery if the highest degree. At the current situation, they stand to lose nothing and all of the games continue on as if nothing happened. All they're doing is screwing THQ out of potential revenue, and essentially making sure Metro tanks due to taking away a core market for the console versions of that game.

    It's a real scumbag move.
  52. PirateNinja
    PirateNinja Maybe I don't get the article you posted. I thought console versions were safe. Are you saying Metro is going to tank because the PC version won't be distributed on Impulse? What about Steam? What percentage of PC gamers actually use Impulse to buy?
  53. UPSLynx
    UPSLynx A shockingly high number, actually. Plus it has more to do with Metro's continuing struggle to get noticed and be marketed to the right audiences.
  54. Tushon
    Tushon ty for info and continuing scumbag gamestop
  55. PirateNinja
    PirateNinja Ya, and for the record if lynx thinks gamestop is scum I won't shop there. Good enough for me :D
  56. Ilriyas
    Ilriyas I stopped shopping at EB Games (Canadian Branch) Around the time they stopped dealing in PC games, hiked their prices, and started putting $5 values on trade-ins they later resold for $60
  57. bright
    bright Gamestop has been scum for as long as I can remember.
  58. mertesn
    mertesn
    Gamestop has been scum for as long as I can remember.
    EB, Software etc, and a bunch of others used to be great places to buy games. What you see now is from an effective lack of competition.
  59. cola
    cola Lynx says Gamestop is scum
    Bite it you Scum is a song by GG Allin
    GG Allin and the Murder Bandits = Punk
    People went to their shows just to get in fights.
    Gamestop: Go there to get in fights.
  60. PirateNinja
    PirateNinja
    Lynx says Gamestop is scum
    Bite it you Scum is a song by GG Allin
    GG Allin and the Murder Bandits = Punk
    People went to their shows just to get in fights.
    Gamestop: Go there to get in fights.
    Seems legit

    EB, Software etc, and a bunch of others used to be great places to buy games.
    Software etc. was awesome, I miss those days.

    ==========================

    Eventually, and soon, there just won't be non-cloud based distributors of software and following that there won't be non-cloud based software. Gamestop has most everything working against it right now short of, in my opinion, a following of parents who buy their kids giftcards to the place because they don't know about steam.

    You can bet your arse I'll be buying the new Metro no matter what Gamestop does or does not do, and I'll be damned if I don't buy a sequel to HomeFront if it is ever made because that game was super fun.
  61. Requit
    Requit

    Apparently we all have been using Gamestop wrong for years.

  62. JBoogaloo
    JBoogaloo

    Well, I now know I have, lol!

  63. Pink
    Pink

    I wonder if I can mortgage to gamestop

  64. mertesn
    mertesn

    Yes, but when you go to sell your house back to them, they'll only give you 30% of its value if it's in perfect condition.

  65. Linc
    Linc

    @UPSLynx said:
    Though I cannot comment on THQ's financial situation (obviously), the company is NOT being sold piecemeal.

    How will I ever trust you again.

  66. NiGHTS
    NiGHTS

    @DaringFireball said:
    That @UPSLynx is a pretty okay guy, trustworthy too.

    ...that should do it.

    edit: ducks

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!