If geeks love it, we’re on it

Thermaltake ProWater 850i

Thermaltake ProWater 850i

Performance Testing

We’re currently making some changes to our testing rigs. We’ll be testing the ProWater 850i on our Intel rig only, as we’re setting up a Phenom rig for future AMD tests. It should be noted that there have been two minor changes to our Intel rig. We have replaced the single 1GB Firestix DIMM with a Corsair XMS2 DIMM. We’ve also replaced the Corsair VX-550 with a Corsair TX-750 power supply. All system configuration settings, frequencies and other hardware components remain consistent with our previous tests. Neither of these changes should be significant enough to impact results and they can be compared to prior tests. For more information on our system configurations, please see our heatsink testing methodology.

As you can see, the ProWater fares very well against the competition. With its fan at full speed, it is able to best even the mighty TRUE 120. Obviously it is a lot louder than the TRUE combined with a Scythe S-FLEX, but it still does very well with the S-FLEX as well. To be perfectly honest, I wasn’t expecting the system to do so well with a single 120mm radiator. I think this is due in part to its excellent base finish and very secure mounting system.

We see a similar trend with “Small FFTs” which is a more intensive test on modern Intel CPUs. The ProWater 850i is able to take the lead over the TRUE 120 by a degree and it doesn’t do quite as well with the quiet S-FLEX fan. It performs about at par with the impressive Sunbeam ‘Core Contact Freezer’.

As expected, the ProWater provides very little cooling to the motherboard components, the chipset and the memory. The only fan used by the ProWater is essentially a case exhaust fan, so none of the board components are receiving much airflow. As with any watercooling system, it is important to ensure you have adequate case airflow or an auxiliary fan directed towards the motherboard. This becomes very important if you plan to do any heavy overclocking.

« Previous Next page »

Comments

  1. BuddyJ
    BuddyJ Sweet article lemonlime! Well done!
  2. lemonlime
    lemonlime Thanks, Buddy J :)

    Here is a shot of the backplate after I took apart the system. Manufacturers really need to steer clear of this area on LGA775 boards. As I mentioned, the padding was thick enough to protect the board.

    attachment.php?attachmentid=26056&stc=1&d=1222997839
  3. jared
    jared Great review Mike!

    Looks like an awesome kit. I wouldn't mind picking one of these up, but I think you might as well add a GPU cooler in there too...
  4. BuddyJ
    BuddyJ They say it's expandable. The pump pushes quite a bit of water; enough for a GPU cooler and 2x120mm radiator.

    I'd like to see how the new OCZ waterblock stacks up when added to this system. It's only $40.
  5. jared
    jared Which one of their kits is the "step up" from this one.

    Didn't they have one that included some of that stuff mentioned above^^

    (specifically the 2x120mm radiator i thought)
  6. BuddyJ
    BuddyJ Right now, the ProWater 850i is their top kit. They sell upgrades individually:
    http://www.thermaltakeusa.com/Products.aspx?C=1162

    I can't find it, but there's a review online somewhere I read last week where they added a Thermaltake GPU block and the 2x120mm radiator to the mix and got better results. I guess the ProWater's pump is strong enough to take mild upgrades. The only real downside I see to the kit (aside from lemonlime's remarks) is the small reservoir. I'm not sure if it can be replaced or not.
  7. muddocktor
    muddocktor I see a few things that I find not too desirable with this kit (besides that mounting bracket that Mike noted). First, the radiator is all aluminum and you have to run some kind of antifreeze mix (which I'm sure that the included coolant that Thermaltake provided contains) or you will have corrosion due to ionic transfer between dissimilar metals. And the pump, while adequate, is not a real powerhouse. Finally, I find a single fan radiator, while easier for mounting purposes, is a bit small for overclocking a quad based system. For the price this is selling for ($135 at the Egg), I would rather spend another $5 more and get the Swiftech H20-220 Compact CPU Water Cooling Kit. With the Swiftech kit you get a double fan brass tank and tube radiator, radbox for mounting the radiator externally and a waterpump/waterblock combo based off of the Apogee GT block and MCP350 pump. There's nothing really bad with this Thermaltake kit but it's competing against a superior Swiftech kit in it's price range.
  8. BuddyJ
    BuddyJ The downside of the Swiftech kit is its upgradability, right? You can change the pump top but you're stuck with their block...
  9. muddocktor
    muddocktor Yeah, that is a minor downside, but if you think about it you probably would be changing the block in the future anyways. And the MCP350 pump side of the combo is fully upgradable with an aftermarket top and there is also a very simple solder mod you can do to the MCP350 to convert it to a MCP355 motor (from 10 watt to 18 watt motor) as they are the same motor on the pump. Martin's Liquid Labs has some good pics of the mod area in their review of the Apogee Drive (the pump/waterblock combo that comes with this kit). This mod could also be done on the present setup to get you a little better flowrate and pressure also.
  10. BuddyJ
    BuddyJ Yeah, I read about the mods etc. on Martin's site. The MCP350 sounds like a great pump. I'd like to get one myself. Are you saying you can detach the pump from the block on the Swifty kit so you can upgrade to a better block like the GTZ? I was under the impression that if you wanted to move to a better waterblock, you also had to get a new pump.
  11. muddocktor
    muddocktor No, the pump body comes off just like pulling the shipping top of the MCP350 and 355. If you install an XSPC top on the pump body and impeller, the only difference between it and a pump you buy as a pump is the lack of the 2 mounting brackets on the sides of the pump body. The waterblock part of the pump comes off just like the top of the regular pump with 4 screws. Here's a link to Martin's review of the Apogee Drive, which shows him mounting an aftermarket top to the pump body of the Drive. It has a pic of the pump body with an aftermarket top mounted on it. Plus, he shows the solder mod clearly too in the article. That is what is so nice about this kit; your pump isn't obsolete when you decide to upgrade to a better waterblock.:thumbup
  12. BuddyJ
    BuddyJ Thanks for clarifying it mudd. The Swiftech kit just became much more appealing.

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!