If geeks love it, we’re on it

Trouble in mobile workstation paradise

Trouble in mobile workstation paradise

As you know from reading my previous three days‘ worth of experiences with the HP EliteBook 8740w mobile workstation, I have been pretty much pleased as punch with this monster so far. It’s unbelievably fast, it’s very light, it’s got the nicest display I’ve ever laid eyes on, and it is absolutely packed to the gills with features.

Alas, sometimes when things seem too good to be true, they are.

Today I decided to start putting the 8740w through its paces. I wanted to get it out on the open road, as it were, and metaphorically floor it. I started downloading 3DMark Vantage, and while I waited for that, I fired up Bioshock just to see what the power draw would be like during gaming. I played for about 15 minutes, which got the machine nice and warm. It was drawing about 165w (not too bad) when I quit the game. I went back to the Windows desktop, launched Tweetdeck, and boom…

Instant shutdown.

I tried pushing the power button, but it wouldn’t start back up. I pulled the battery, pulled the power, let it sit for 5 minutes, and it still wouldn’t start back up. I unplugged the power brick, waiting two minutes until the green power LED on the brick went off, then tried again. Nothing. The lights flashed briefly on the 8740w, but that’s it.

I tried starting it with and without the battery installed. Nothing.

I decided to let it cool down, because it was rather hot after playing Bioshock, so I left it alone for five hours until it was completely cooled down. Then I tried powering it up again and this time, lo and behold, it made it all the way to Windows, and even let me log in. My elation was short-lived, however. A few seconds later, it was dead again, and would not turn back on.

To me, it almost feels like the same sort of behavior that happens when a heatsink pops off the CPU; the machine gets too hot too fast due to no heatsink contact, and shuts down in seconds. Try as you might, unless you let it cool completely down, you cannot start it. That’s just my layman’s feeling, however.

Hey, I promised to take an in-depth look at this thing, and this is actually providing a perfect opportunity to do just that. I’m going to see how good the in-home warranty support is (although I’m not sure if this particular machine is covered under it because of its status as a review piece.) We’ll have to see.

I’ll let you guys know how the support process goes. Stay tuned!

Continue on to day 5 of my experience blog.

Comments

  1. drasnor
  2. Cliff_Forster
    Cliff_Forster Craming desktop class componenets into a laptop enclosure is always a tricky proposition.
  3. MAGIC
    MAGIC Water cool it.
  4. Garg
    Garg Build a giant bong cooler, strap some casters on it, and you've got a "mobile" water cooling solution.
  5. Tim
    Tim This is not good, for such an expensive laptop to screw up so easily. I'll still be happy to accept the other one, though. :)

    You'd think HP would be more careful with building the laptops they KNEW were going out for reviews.
  6. ardichoke
    ardichoke You wouldn't have to worry about it though tim.... IE6 won't push that hardware nearly enough to make it even warm.
  7. GHoosdum
    GHoosdum I was hoping your D&D session would be accomplished from the quiet comfort and safety of your own room this week, but alas, it is not to be. :(
  8. DarkStarr Really? Is this a surprise? HP sucks, Dell isn't much better, along with several others. Either way it = Epic fail on HPs part since it was brand new and wasn't abused and it was for a review.
  9. Tim
    Tim So what's the news on this HP? Haven't seen any new reports for a few days now.
  10. Ryder
    Ryder It broke on Thanksgiving (25th) 2 whole business days (depending on who you are) since then. Probably hasn't even made it to HP yet :)

    Just my guess though.
  11. primesuspect
    primesuspect I've got a post coming tonight. Anxious, Tim? :D
  12. Kwitko
    Kwitko I think I deserve this machine because I actually watched the videos for the AMD video card challenge. Plus I'm poor. Plus you owe me for not coming to NYC.
  13. Tim
    Tim Doesn't this computer have a warranty where the technician comes to YOU to fix it? I read that in the story.
  14. primesuspect

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!